Showing posts with label Morals. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Morals. Show all posts

Wednesday, June 18, 2014

Kış uykusu

(Yazıda filmdeki olaylarla ilgili bilgiler olduğundan izlemeden okumamanızı tavsiye edeceğim :)

Öncelikle şunu söyleyeyim, Kış Uykusu'nu çok sevdim. En sevdiğim tarafı da, karakterlerinin  tutarsızlıklarının üstüne çekinmeden gidişi oldu. Babasından kalan Kapadokya'daki evi otel olarak işleten eski tiyatrocu Aydın, kız kardeşi Necla ve kendisinden genç karısı Nihal, sert kış mevsimini Kapadokya'da geçirmektedirler. Aydın boş zamanlarında yerel gazete için köşe yazarlığı yapmakta, "Türk Tiyatrosunun Tarihi" isimli kalın ve ciddi bir kitap yazmayı planlamaktadır. Buna karşılık hayatlarını doğrudan etkileyebileceği insanlara karşı ilgisizdir: Entelektüel çalışmalarına vakit ayırabilmek için sahip olduğu mülklerin yönetimini tamamen yardımcısına ve avukatlarına bırakmıştır. Vicdan ve ahlaktan sıkça bahsetmesine rağmen, kirayı ödeyemedikleri için evlerine icra gelen imam Hamdi ve ailesinin çektikleri sıkıntılara ilgisiz kalır, imamdan kaçınmak için bahaneler üretir. Aydın aslında her şeyi kendisi için yapmaktadır, Nihal'in tartışmaları sırasında söylediği gibi kendisini doğrudan ilgilendirmeyen bir konuda bir şey hissedememektedir. Nihal'in hayırseverlik girişimlerine yardım etmeye kalkışır, ama bunun asıl nedeni kendisini onun karşısında güçsüz ve dışlanmış hissetmesidir. Aydın'ın tutarsızlıklarını belki de en iyi Nihal anlamaktadır: Aslında Aydın ne inançsızları, ne inançlıları, ne gençleri, ne yaşlıları, ne de "halk"ı sevmektedir.

Necla, Aydın'ın çalışma masasının arkasındaki koltuğa oturup ağabeyinin yazdığı gazeteyi ve yazılarını rahatlıkla eleştirebilmekte, onları önemsiz bulduğunu neredeyse sevimsizliğe varan bir açık sözlülükle söyleyebilmektedir. Necla bir bakıma filmin Vasfiye Teyze'sidir! Ona göre Aydın, ıvır zıvırla uğraşmakta, gerçekten önemli bir şeyler yapmamaktadır. Buna karşılık kendisi de günlerini can sıkıntısı içinde geçirmekte, ona haksızlık etmiş eski kocasına dönebilmek için bahane aramakta, insanın "kendisine kötülük edene karşı çıkmayarak" ona hatasından dönme fırsatı verebileceğini iddia etmektedir. Burda bir nevi günah işleme özgürlüğünden bahsediliyor sanırım!

Nihal ise içinde yaşadığı boşluğu hayırseverlik girişimleriyle ve bu girişimleri sayesinde edindiği ahbaplarıyla doldurmaya çalışmaktadır. Aydın ve Necla'nın kusurlarını, Aydın'ın "suçlarını" rahatlıkla görebilmekte, ama yıllardır Aydın'dan ayrılacak gücü bulamamaktadır. Belki de filmin en etkileyici sahnesi, Nihal'in Aydın'ın İstanbul'a gittiğini sandığı gece, Aydın'ın hayırseverlik için bıraktığı parayı alıp imamın evini ziyarete gitmesidir. Böylece hem Aydın'ı kendi işine karıştırmayarak bağımsızlığını koruyacak, hem de Aydın'ın duyarsızlığını telafi edecektir. Ancak ailenin başına gelenleri geriye döndürmek mümkün değildir ve imam Hamdi'nin gururlu ve bencil kardeşi İsmail, Nihal'e vicdanını rahatlatma fırsatını vermez.

Nuri Bilge Ceylan'ın Cannes röportajlarında (burada ve burada) hep üstünde durduğu bir tema var: İnsanın kendi zayıflıklarını farkedip, kabul edip, bunları itiraf etmesinin değeri. Ceylan, Türk toplumunda insanların zayıflıklarını gizleyip kendilerini olmadıkları kadar güçlü göstermek zorunda kaldığını, bunun aslında büyük bir yük olduğunu, siyasetçilerin de destek kaybetmemek için hatalarını asla kabul etmediklerini söylüyor. Filmde hem kendisinde ve kendi çevresindeki kişilerde gözlemlediği tutarsızlıkları gösteriyor, hem de izleyiciye kendi tutarsızlıklarını, zayıflıklarını görebilmeleri için ayna tutuyor. Aynı karakterlerin birbirlerine yaptıkları gibi. Aslında sanatın amacı bu, gerçeği gösterebilmek. Kimsenin hoşuna gitmese de.
.

Sunday, December 16, 2012

Kötülük üzerine

“Schiller'in güzel insanlarında hep böyledir: Son ana dek yüceltirler insanı, son dakikaya dek her şeyi iyiye yorarlar, asla kötülük beklemezler; madalyonun öteki yanını sezinler gibi olsalar bile, söylenmesi gereken sözcüğü kesinlikle söylemezler. Kötüyü düşünmek bile yılgınlığa düşürür onları. Ellerini kollarını sallayarak gerçeği uzaklaştırmaya çalışırlar. Ta ki, yücelttikleri insan burunlarını kırana dek..." Suç ve Ceza, sayfa 57.

(Yaratıcı Yazarlık Atölyesi Egzersizi)
Kötülük çoğu zaman zayıflıktan daha fazlası değildir. Kötüleri anlamaya çalışan insanlar sorarlar kendilerine, bir insan böyle bir kötülüğü nasıl yapabilir diye. Oysa ben kimsenin yaptığı şeye kötülük dediğini görmedim. İnsan bir şeyi yapmak istedi mi, akıl işgüzar küçük bir hizmetçi gibi koşar imdadına, tepsiler içinde bahaneler getirir. İnsan yapmayı istediği şeyin kötülük olmadığına inandırır kendini önce. O bahaneleri buldu mu hiç unutmamalı, onlara inancını kaybetmemeli. Ya da belki büsbütün unutmalı, üzerlerinde hiç düşünmemeli. O zaman en doğrusunu yapmıştım işte, şartlar öyle gerektiriyordu, daha farklı bir karar verilemezdi. Kim olsa aynısını yapardı.
Dışardakiler de kötülüğü gerçek hayatta gördüler mi öyle hemen teşhis edivermeye hazır değiller. Bir de ona sor, kimbilir ne sebepleri vardır derler. Kendini bir onun yerine koy bakalım, daha başka davranabilecek miydin. Helal olsun daha iyisini yapabilene.
Birinin kötü olduğunu, kötülük yaptığını baştan kabul ederek insanın onu anlamaya, yaptığını anlamlandırmaya çalışması en zoru. Belki de kötülüğü anlamlandırmak mümkün olmadığından ona yakın bir şeye başvuruyoruz: Zayıflık.

Saturday, August 20, 2011

Why not?

I first heard about the Tree of Life when it won the Palme d'Or in the same Cannes Festival where Nuri Bilge Ceylan won the grand jury award with his film Once Upon a Time in Anatolia. From what I gathered, Terrence Malick and his movie sounded mysterious and different. I read the two very positive reviews written by Peter Bradshaw in the Guardian, and this concept stuck in my mind: "And all the time, gigantic scenes from the secret life of the cosmos endow these family dramas with something alienated, bewildering – a sense of a terrifying new perspective in which their traumas are vanishingly tiny and yet have an excruciating new spiritual magnitude."

I went to see the movie on a rainy day in London, and trusting Bradshaw, I was completely prepared to get carried away and be impressed by it. And so I was. I think what the movie does is remind the viewers of the grandness and incredibility of the cosmos and the nature, and one doesn't need to see the "light" and dinosaurs and flowing lava to remember it, just looking at a big tree against rays of sunshine would suffice, but we seem to have forgotten it regardless. And we are part of that nature, and with all our numbers and experience and pride, it is nature that guides us, not the other way around. We are small and unimportant, and we all experience similar things. Similar scenes are repeated millions of times across the world.

And yet, are we? The story of the family and everyone's joy, pain, aspirations and disappointments gain such great proportions in the movie that you can compare the joy to the sunshine and the pain to the lava. So Malick appreciates not only the nature (and its creator) but also what each one of us has to go through every day and how we cope with it. I empathized with the father's struggles through the world's drudgery as much as I admired the mother's untainted goodness, heavenly "way of grace."

Bradshaw says that the movie created a "Christianityless metaphysics" for him. And so it did inspire a religionless metaphysics for me. Having not pondered about these questions (everything is random, one shall not seek for meaning, just for a refuge) for a while, and having had weak faith (if any at all) during this time, the movie did give rise to this question in my mind: Why not? We don't have any evidence either way, so having no faith is a form of faith in itself.

Maybe the real issue is the loss of faith in humanity.

Tuesday, August 09, 2011

Suç ve Ceza
(Kitabı okumadıysanız bu yazıyı okumayın lütfen, kitapta ne varsa yazacağım çünkü.)

Romanın ana karakteri Raskolnikov, bir fikrin esiri olmuştur: Bütün yasaklara rağmen dünyaya yararı olmayan, hatta zararlı olduğunu düşündüğü bir kocakarıyı öldürmek, kötülük sayılamaz. Raskolnikov’a gore ancak bağımsız düşüncelerini herkese rağmen eyleme dönüştürme yürekliliğini gösteren insanlar “seçkin” sayılabilirler, ancak bu yürekliliği gösterebilecek insanların iktidara sahip olma hakkı vardır. Raskolnikov kadını öldürürken, bir bakıma da kendisinin “seçkin” insanlardan biri olup olmadığını test etmektedir. Ancak daha kadını öldürürken paniğe kapılır; kadının masum kız kardeşini de öldürmek zorunda kalır, güç bela ve tamamen şans eseri olay mahallinden kaçar ve suçunu itiraf edene kadar psikolojisi o kadar bozulur ki tüm şüpheleri üzerine çeker.

Raskolnikov daha fazla dayanamayıp suçunu itiraf etmeden once bile işlediği cinayetin bir suç ve günah olduğunu kabul etmez: Kendisi için hayatı çekilmez hale getiren suçluluk duygusu değil, “aklıyla” doğruluğunu bildiği eyleminin arkasında duracak kadar yürekli olamayışıdır. Telaşa, paniğe, korkuya kapıldığı için seçkin bir insan olamamıştır, iktidarı hak etmemiştir.

Raskolnikov eyleminin temelindeki fikri inatla savumayı sürdürse, savaşlarda masum insanların öldürülmesi kabul edilirken kendi suçunun böylesine kınanmasındaki ikiyüzlülüğe isyan etse de, adaleti sağlamaya çalışırken yol açtığı adaletsizlikleri görmezden gelemiyor olmalıydı: Masum bir insanı öldürmüş, masum bir diğer insanın hapse düşmesine yol açmıştı. Olmalıydı diyorum, çünkü Raskolnikov’un karmakarışık duyguları içinde böyle bir vicdan azabını ancak Raskolnikov ölen kız kardeş Livazeta’nın Sonya’nın tek arkadaşı olduğunu öğrenince açıkça seçebildim. Bu insanlar kuşkusuz Raskolnikov’un tanımına gore seçkin değildiler, sıradan insanlardılar, ama iktidar sahibi birinin yapması gerektiği gibi sıradan insanları, bir fikri savunmak için “ödenmesi gereken bir bedel” olarak göremiyordu.

Kitabın sonunda Raskolnikov iyi karakter Sonya’ya aşık olmayı başardığında, bir eşiği geçer: Artık onun için teoriler bitmiş, yaşam başlamıştır. Sıradan bir insan oluşunu dert etmeyi, sıradan insanları küçümsemeyi bırakır. Dostoyevski büyük teorilere, taammüden sıradışı bir şeyler yapmaya çalışan insanlara büsbütün mü karşıdır, yoksa aşkı sıradan insanlara sıradanlıklarını unutturabilecek bir teselli armağanı, sığınak olarak mı görür, orasını bilemiyorum.

Sanırım Dostoyevski, insanların çektiği acılara ve başa çıkamadıkları talihsizliklere asla kayıtsız kalamamakla birlikte (Raskolnikov Sonya’ya ilk ziyaretinde onun önünde eğildiğinde, onun değil, insanlığın çektiği acıların önünde eğilmiştir,) adaleti sağlamaya çalışan fikirlerin hiç birine inanmıyordu. Her insanın once kendini kurtarmasının topluma daha faydalı olacağı fikrini Lujin kadar sevimsiz bir karaktere söyletiyor, komün kurmaya çalışan iyi yürekli ama saf Lebezyatnikov’un “ilerleme” fikri ve akılcı bir düzen hayalleriyle ise açıkça dalga geçiyordu. Sonya’nın Tanrı’nın izin vermeyeceğine inandığı bütün felaketlere, Raskolnikov’un da öngördüğü gibi Tanrı izin verecek oluyor, ancak Svidrigaylov gibi bir günahkarın vicdan azabı ile yaptığı yardım mani oluyordu. Gerçi inanan biri burada Tanrı’nın müdahale ettiğini iddia edebilir.

Dostoyevski’nin 150 yıl once kıtabında açıkladığı fikirlerin, çatışmaların hiç değilse böyle şeylere kafa yoranlar için taptaze sürüyor olması Dostoyevski’nin dehasının göstergesi midir, yoksa insanlığın bütün teknolojik gelişmeye rağmen ahlaki yönden geri kalmışlığının mı?

Saturday, April 24, 2010

Welcome and unwelcome difficulties

I read Alain de Botton's Consolations of Philosophy a couple of weeks ago, and there he said that anger isn't an irrational power that comes over us, boils our blood and blinds our reason, but it's actually an emotion sparked by a thought, a rational assumption: That life and people should be easier and fairer and better. And as we learn more about the world and how it is not in fact that easy or fair or good, we will cease to be angry and try to summon the power to live with what we can't change. (To his credit, de Botton also realizes that aqueducts wouldn't have been built without discontent with the status quo. But he argues that we should discern between the things we can change and those we can't to put an end to futile discontent.)

When they see me angry or disappointed, people tell me that such is life. And I know that any project or relationship is so much more difficult than it seems when you start it. Last weekend I played scrabble with some friends at the Heath and I realized how you might have the perfect word on your rack, but everybody is trying to get their word out there and you may not find a place on the board for the ideal, and if you want to keep playing, you have to come up with another solution, no matter how unideal it is.

But then there must be a border between what is normal and should be expected and what is unacceptable. As I grow up, that border moves out for me and I realize how much work everything entails and I'm not entitled to anything, but the border is still, and always, there. And that border is crossed when somebody doesn't play by the rules. I know there is no single set of rules (or values, yes), but I still believe that we should hold on to whatever sense of fairness and justice we have and not let it vanish. We should trust our gut feeling and be prepared to stand our ground despite any practical concern or fear. Such situations call for fighting, not staying silent or adjusting.

The welcome difficulty of getting over the unwelcome obstacle.

Because when that border disappears, meaning and value disappears and you cease to care. And that is as good as dead.

Saturday, October 10, 2009

From a "global market" to a "global society" - 2

This article is the edited version of my long response to Nihan's From a "Global Market" to a "Global Society".

Constructivism argues that actors' understanding of the pay-offs may change without an actual shift in material interests. In crisis situations actors may be open to new ideas, as they realize that what they have always believed in does not work. A crisis provides the "policy window" for a charismatic actor ("an institutional entrepreneur") to come up with new ideas and persuade the other actors. As they interact and negotiate ("social learning" within the existing institutional framework,) actors change their minds about the pay-offs associated with each option.

A change in values could be what is meant by a change in pay-offs. The important point is having greater awareness about the non-immediate consequances of our actions. Once we are aware, we feel more responsible. Realizing the far-away consequences of our individual actions, inactions and transactions is key to an evolution from a “global market” to a “global society”. There are people who can no longer bring themselves to drive SUVs, or throw a glass bottle away without recycling it, because they are not able to act despite their knowledge. People should think about security and development issues in the same way, as well as the cross-border regulations and supervision of financial markets. Western societies are no longer isolated from the poverty and violence in "remote" corners of the world. Injustice breeds insecurity. Not only politicians, but “thought leaders” from all fields have a duty to tell these hard truths without commercializing or sensationalizing the subject.

It is time for leaders to evaluate their assumptions about their constituents. Are we knights, or are we knaves? Knaves are self-interested, they serve others only when that will serve their own material interests. Knights, on the other hand, put the interests of those they serve above their own. They serve others even when they gain no material reward, or they actually face a cost doing so (Le Grand, 2003).

The resulting organizational structure will be reinforcing the assumptions that gave rise to it. When a leader thinks that his constituents are knaves, he mistrusts them and treats them like naughty children. He tries to keep information hidden because he is afraid that he will be punished for telling the truth. He establishes a structure that is based on close monitoring, strong incentives and harsh penalties, even if they are not always enforced. The constituents will perceive this system as a controlling form of external intervention, which leaves no room for intrinsic motivation, inquiry and innovation.

What if we are more knights than knaves?

The questions that need to be asked to bring about the transition from a "global market" to a "global society" can be very exciting and inspiring. They give people’s lives a meaning beyond day-to-day survival characterised by tedious office jobs, family lives and consumerism. They give each person a stake in improving the humanity’s well-being, bringing about change. This is what today’s left-wing politics should embrace. People would be far more receptive to this than we (and politicians) think. Only one leader fully grasps this: Obama.

Saturday, October 03, 2009

Isolated actions and usual suspects

Since Polish/French director Roman Polanski got arrested, I am trying to come up with a consistent way to think about this: I'm trying to put his actions in different compartments, so that his raping a young girl has no bearing on his films, and his films have no bearing on his crime. But while the latter seems so obvious to me, his crime will always hang over like a shadow over his films. I feel the same about two Turkish columnists, Deniz Gökçe and Sevan Nişanyan, who have degraded their wives in much-publicized cases of domestic violence. It's not even like what they think and write is genius, for the record, they always have that bad-ass attitude whenever they write or say something. But even if they said something bright, I don't know if I could open my mind wide enough to let it in.

It is easier to disentangle things when I think of the Doğan Group. At first my view of them as victims in their spat with the government was tinged with the knowledge that all these years, they used their newspapers to secure favors. This is karmic justice, their bomb exploded in their hands. They never said anything to fix what was wrong when things were going their way, did they? But then I realized that this in no way frees the government of the responsibility to fix things, replace this power game with the rule of law, where journalists do their jobs and bureaucrats do, too. Judges will (hopefully) not allow their judgement in one case to blur their understanding of another one.

But when looking at an art work or reading the wise words of someone who claims to be an authority in economics or linguistics, I am the judge. And I can't prevent my knowledge about the person from standing in the way of my full understanding. I can't put my trust in them enough to lend my eyes and ears to them. It may be simplistic to say only good people produce good work, but I can safely say that I only really listen to good people. Because really listening to someone or really looking at what they show you requires to let them guide you for a while.

That said, over the past few years I have come to realize and accept that good people may be inconsistent, inconsistency is sometimes nothing but the passage of time and people can change their minds and break their promises, people may be good despite their mistakes. It is not always wise to throw something or someone overboard just because they disappointed me once or twice. But it's also not wise to forgive anything and everything. Our actions do point at something about us, sometimes to fundamental personality defects. Moments of weakness are not always moments, they are not completely arbitrary or unintended.

Monday, August 24, 2009

"It was true that a person of great faith could with impunity have acted boldly: It was only that Michael was not that person. What he failed to do was accurately to estimate his own resources, his own spiritual level: and it was indeed from his later reflections on this matter that he had, with a certain bitterness, drawn the text for his sermon. One must perform the lower act which one can manage and sustain: not the higher act which one bungles." Iris Murdoch, the Bell, page 207.

"'We are both boulder-pushers.' This is his phrase for what he sees as his own failure. His fight to get out of his poor background, to win scholarships, to get the highest medical degrees, came out of an ambition to be a creative scientist. But he knows now he will never be this original scientist. And this defect has been partly caused by what is best in him, his abiding, tireless compassion for the poor, the ignorant, the sick. He has always, at a point when he should have chosen the library or the laboratory, chosen the weak instead. He will never now be a discoverer or a blazer of new paths. He has become a man who fights a middle-class, reactionary medical superintendent who wants to keep his wards locked and his patients in straitjackets. 'You and I, Ella, we are the failures. We spend our lives fighting to get people very slightly more stupid than ourselves to accept the truths that the great men have always known. They have known for thousands of years that a poor man who is frightened of his landlord and of the police is a slave. They have known it. We know it. But do the great enlightened mass of the British people know it? No. It is our task, Ella, yours and mine, to tell them. Because the great men are too great to be bothered. They are already discovering how to colonize Venus and to irrigate the moon. That is what is important for our time. You and I are the boulder-pushers. All our lives, you and I, we'll put all our energies, all our talents, into pushing a great boulder up a mountain. The boulder is the truth that the great men know by instinct, and the mountain is the stupidity of mankind.'" Doris Lessing, the Golden Notebook, page 195-196.

"What is terrible is that after every one of the phases of my life is finished, I am left with no more than some banal commonplace that everyone knows: in this case, that women's emotions are all still fitted for a kind of society that no longer exists. My deep emotions, my real ones, are to do with my relationship with a man. One man. But I don't live that kind of life, and I know few women who do. So what I feel is irrelevant and silly... I am always coming to the conclusion that my real emotions are foolish, I am always having, as it were, to cancel myself out. I ought to be like a man, caring more for my work than for people; I ought to put my work first, and take men as they come, or find an ordinary comfortable man for bread and butter reasons - but I won't do it, I can't be like that..." Doris Lessing, the Golden Notebook, page 283.

Ideas and actions

My friends were over for dinner and we were discussing whether we have a moral duty to help others, others who are less fortunate than ourselves. One of them suggested that big principles won't translate into action. Actions spring not from ideas or opinions but somewhere else, from a well of emotion. It may be years before grand theories spark up emotions. Everybody likes the idea of performing noble acts. How many of us are actually pushing the boulder?

That is why religions manipulated fear and guilt to motivate people into doing the "right thing". That's how magnificent churches were built. Aren't most of our actions (and inactions) still driven by fear and guilt? Maybe that is why it is so difficult to create a secular morality, it is so difficult to get people to feel and do anything. They tell us people are suffering, women are being trafficked, climate change will bring disaster if we don't care - they sound like a false alarm, we just look at them and wonder what's in all this for them. Are we supposed to respect them for their grasp of the truth and high moral sense? And mind you, if there's anything in it for them, we will feel much better because we won't have to question ourselves and change our behavior.

One of my friends says how important it is to live up to your principles, matching action with ideas. But are we those people, do we possess the emotional energy to back up our ideals?

So maybe the only way to understand who we are is to look at what we do, and what we don't.

Sunday, August 02, 2009

animal spirits

It's been a long time since a book inspired me not to quote it, but write about it. I got Iris Murdoch's Bell from the second-hand book stalls under the Waterloo bridge. The themes it was addressing, I have been thinking about myself recently. More than talking about the book per se, I would like to explore these themes.

The book follows the thoughts and feelings of three members of a layman's religious community in West England. It primarily deals with the dichotomy between relativism vs. absolutism, as the characters search for the absolute truth, only to find that it is unattainable. Just like the enclosed grounds of the abbey across the lake, which is home to an order of nuns, truth and purity are there, theoretically possible, but out of reach.

Michael, the leader of the community, cannot find the strength in himself to live up to absolute moral standards in the face of love and desire. Dora, the erring wife, finds it impossible to grasp herself and the people around her as they really are; only the paintings in the National Gallery are able to comfort her with their absolute beauty - true beyond her interpretation. Toby, the young and wholesome boy, loses his carefree innocence with a simple kiss, falling into desperate confusion.

And all this seems to stem from one simple fact: The human condition, the mess we find ourselves in. Our minds sitting on top of an elephant of emotion, struggling to ride it. Sometimes it fails. And our curse is precisely this: We are aware of having lost control of the elephant, and we are aware that the elephant is taking us to the gutter. We are aware that nobody in their right minds would be doing what we are doing. We are aware that we are not interpreting people, situations correctly. But we simply don't know how to interpret them, what the truth is. Only if we had a manual to describe how people actually are. The whole thing has the urgency and inevitability of a disaster, and we are as helpless as in a dream.

That's why we worship and seek the absolute - wisdom, love, rules to live by. Only because we know we are unable to attain them. They are just ideas in the poor rider's head, the residue of a lost day and age, when people weren't as free to so visibly succumb to their weaknesses. But ideas and expectations remain; they continue to fool us into believing that something better is possible. We don't fail to be caught off guard every time reality falls short of what ought to be.

I should give the last word to poor Michael, who so eloquently explains that we are only entitled to the compass that is within us, and nothing else:

"In each of us there are different talents, different propensities, many of them capable of good or evil use. We must endeavour to know our possibilities and use what energy we really possess in the doing of God's will. As spiritual beings, in our imperfections and also in the possibility of our perfection, we differ profoundly one from another. How different we are from each other is something which it may take a long time to find out; and certain differences may never appear at all. Each one of us has his own way of apprehending God. I am sure you will know what I mean when I say that one finds God, as it were, in certain places; one has, where God is concerned, a sense of direction, a sense that here is what is most real, most good, most true. This sense of reality and weight attaches itself to certain experiences in our lives - and for different people these experiences may be different. God speaks to us in various tongues. To this, we must be attentive." pg. 209-210.

Wednesday, May 13, 2009

One Heart

Last week I went to a lecture at the LSE by Professor Conor Gearty, the former director of the school's Centre for the Study of Human Rights. The lecture was titled, "Human Rights after Darwin: is a general theory of human rights now possible?" Professor Gearty looked for the reasons of why we emphatize with and care for others in evolutionary psychology. He said caring for others' feelings and cooperative behaviour might have developed because these attitudes created the highest chances of survival and reproductive success. This could also explain how moral values, laws, religion, philosophy and literature came about. Moreover, these feelings were eventually divorced from the direct gains we could expect from performing them. The only utility we gained from caring for someone could be the pleasure of seeing their well-being (and our contribution to it). As a natural extension of this logic, we could emphatize with and care about people whom we don't know at all, and who will never return our favour. (Except maybe by karma points in this world or another.)

Professor Gearty, however, was quick to accept that caring for our kin and community took precedence over caring for strangers. If we perceive the interests of our kin and those of strangers to be in conflict, we would inevitably take sides with our kin. It seems to me that most of us have an inalienable need to care and feel and contribute to others' well-being. It is required for our happiness and fulfillment. It is a well of moral energy that needs to be used up, that needs to be channelled. However, the most essential requirements for survival are our first priority. Then comes the well-being of our family and friends. If all is well, and if we still have the time and energy and courage to notice (because choosing to look over misery is nothing but an excuse for inaction, laziness), then we start genuinely emphatizing with people we don't know about, and do something to change something for them. (Even then, I would be more likely to feel strongly about the problems in Turkey than those in another country.)

This is true on the level of individuals, people and governments. If we feel our survival and well-being to be threatened by others, their feelings and well-being will never matter to us. That's why the unjustified fear and paranoia created by indoctrination, history and received opinions can be so dangerous.

But can we really emphatize, can we really understand how others feel? Can we assume that just because our nature obliges us to care, there is a true and universal understanding of wellness and happiness? Does the urge to move forward mean that we are all moving towards a single point? Do we know where we are going, where we should be going?

Here the question of cultural relativism vs. universalism comes into stage. Can we really understand the struggle for survival and suffering when we have never struggled, suffered? Can we know the good and the best for others? Do they want for themselves what we want for them?

I believe in universal rights that stem simply from the dignity of being human. Everybody deserves them, even when they don't know it or when they are too pre-occupied with barely surviving to fight for it. What matters, however, is how we go about reaching these common goals. It is very important to understand people's values, their first and foremost needs and priorities, the context. And this takes hard work and we may be frustrated. The definition of good may be universal, but the definition of improvement differs from one community to the other. One community may need clean water, another may be trapped in violent conflict, and another might be fighting for political rights and freedom of expression. It is very important to attend to the reality of the local situation if we genuinely have people's well-being (and not our high ideals) at heart. Realism is better than idealism.


***
Once I thought that I had two hearts and they excluded each other. I wasn't happy with either of them. But now I realize they are knitted to each other with tiny strings, veins and arteries, they are in fact one. They feed each other constantly and grow from one another. If one were to shrink, the other would suffer, too.

There's no better way than being loved and believed in for what one is to gratify one's self. That little core in me shines, throbs with joy, expands. On the other hand, loving and caring is essential to happiness (for reasons I explained above), and it can be quite a selfish business. Sometimes I want to tell people (and my little calculating, doubting brain) - just let me be naive and stupid and care for something, even when I won't get anything in return, because I need to feel! I think sometimes we feel bitter when our love is not returned, not just because we are not loved back, and our ego suffers, but because we are denied the possibility to love, to make someone happy. It is so difficult having to do nothing when you want to do lots.

And when you expect lots in return, doing lots is selfish. Loving without expecting constant gratification in return is only possible when you are at peace with yourself.

Saturday, April 25, 2009

Medenileşmek

Şunu bir arkadaşıma yazdım, hoşuma gitti buraya da koyuyorum:

...

Davranışlarımızın biyolojik sebepleri konusunda bir süredir düşünüyorum. Yakın zamanda Altın Defter kitabında bir bölüm okudum. Bir grup ilkbaharda kırlık bir yere gidiyorlar ve bir sürü çekirgeyle kelebek görüyorlar. Bir çoğalma, yenilip yutulup azalma, sonra yeniden çoğalma, böylelikle türünü devam ettirme şeklinde sürüp giden bir döngü. Sonra şöyle bir konuşma geçiyor, alıntılayım:

"This country (Güney Afrika'dan bahsediyorlar, 2. Dünya Savaşı sırasında) is larger than Spain. It contains one and a half million blacks, if one may mention them at all, and one hundred thousand whites. That, in itself, is a thought which demands two minutes' silence. And what do we see? One might imagine - one would have every excuse for imagining, despite what you say, Comrade Willi, that this insignificant handful of sand on the beaches of time -not bad, that image?- unoriginal, but always apt - this million-and-a-little-over-a-half people exist in this pretty piece of God's earth solely in order to make each other miserable..." Here Willi picked up his book again and applied his attention to it. "Comrade Willi, let your eyes follow the print but let the ears of your soul listen. For the facts are - the facts - that there's enough food here for everyone! -enough materials for houses for everyone! - enough talent though admittedly so well hidden under bushels at the moment that nothing but the most generous eye could perceive it - enough talent, I say, to create light where now darkness exists."

"From which you deduce?" said Willi.

"I deduce nothing. I am being stuck by a new... it's a blinding light, nothing less..."

"But what you say is the truth about the whole world, not just this country," said Maryrose.

"Magnificent Maryrose! Yes. My eyes are being opened to - Comrade Willi, would you not say that there is some principle at work not yet admitted to our philosophy? Some principle of destruction?" (The Golden Notebook, Doris Lessing, pg. 378-379)

Bence bu bölüm sorunu çok iyi açıklıyor. Bir yanda aklımız, vicdanımız, doğru bildiklerimiz var. Diğer yanda ise içgüdülerimiz, isteklerimiz. Her yerde insanlar ölüyor, açlık, sefalet çekiyor, birbirleriyle savaşıyor, erkekler kadınları dövüyor, tecavüz ediyor. Doğal afetlerde insanların binlercesi bir anda kayboluyor. Bir tarafta da insanlar zenginlik içinde, kendi doğalarına ve doğaya hükmetmişler, dünyanın geri kalanını geri buluyor. AB vatandaşlarının Türkiye'yi nasıl gördüğü üzerine bir rapor üzerinde çalışırken şunu okumuştum: Medenileşmenin birinci göstergesi, erkeğin gücünü kontrol altında tutabilmesiymiş. Tamam, doğru. Ama medeni ve gelişmiş toplumların sorumluluğu burada bitiyor mu? Bence gerçekten medenileşmek, insanların, toplumların içlerindeki mücadele, elde etme ve diğerlerini yok etme güdüsünü kontrol altına alabilmesi, kendisinden kötü durumdakilere yardım edebilmesi, elindekileri paylaşabilmesiyle olur. O yüzden dünyadaki en gelişmiş toplumların bile medeni olduğunu söyleyemeyiz. (Sanırım bir zamanlar devrim düşleyenler gerçek bir medenileşme arzuluyorlardı. Şimdi kapitalizmin 'insan doğasına', hayatta kalma ve elde etme içgüdümüze en uygun düzen olduğunu söyleyenler de son cevabı vermiş olmanın rahatlığı içindeler.)

Ben senin bahsettiğin determinizme tam olarak katılmıyorum, katılmak istemiyorum. Eğer aklımız, bilincimiz varsa, bir toplum bilinci varsa, bunu kullanmak gerekir. İçimizdeki yok etme, başkalarının pahasına yükselme güdüsünü kontrol altına alabilmek... Mümkün olduğunca medeni ve adil bir yaşam sürmeye çalışmak... Anlamlı, insanların hayatını iyileştirecek, kolaylaştıracak bir şeyler yapmak, yaratmak. Günlük hayatımıza yükleyebileceğimiz bir anlam varsa da, bu yönde göstereceğimiz çaba olmalı. Ama bilmiyorum bu mümkün mü, yoksa hep bilardo topları gibi, vicdan azabı içinde yaşamak zorunda mı kalacağız. Kendimize rağmen istemediğimiz şeyleri yaparak.

Saturday, March 14, 2009

What you thought you knew (but didn't actually know) about Turkey - 2
  • How democratic is the AKP?

Western policy makers once thought that the AKP would lead to a more democratic society, and Turkey would then demonstrate the compatibility of Islam and democracy for other Muslim countries in the Middle East. (Of course, one of the purposes of our lives is to play guinea pigs in western experiments.) Turkey's liberal intelligentsia thought the displacement of the old elite in power would bring about a liberal democracy. So far, this elite seems to have been replaced by a new elite, and the AKP supporters seem to have penetrated and dominated state institutions, instead of making them more transparent and accountable. The same power game is being played, simply by a new player.

Let's take a step back first, and question whether the AKP leadership has really internalized liberal democratic values. The authors say, "Islamic conservatism is not yet at peace with an understanding of secularism that calls for the withdrawal of religion from public realm, which in turn is a prerequisite for liberal democracy." They remind us Erdogan's words, "democracy is a street car, from which we jump off after we reach our destination."

More recently, Erdogan said, "we only took the immorality of the West, not its science." The authors respond, "The Turkish intellectual debate has been haunted by the same expectation since westernization started in the 19th century, namely that it would somehow reveal itself to be possible to acquire the science and technology of the west without having to import western freedom of the mind, specifically the freedom to inquire about and question religious beliefs." The latest incident in TUBITAK (where one of the AKP-appointed administrators censored the stories about Darwin in the TUBITAK magazine, Bilim-Teknik) demonstrates this point vividly.

If you put different pieces of the story together, the picture is quite striking. AKP appoints its supporters to state institutions based on their political loyalty, not merit or competence. (Let's say they pick from a sub-set of supporters, rather than all the possible candidates for the job.) They award government contracts to supporters (ranging from local constructors, who build roads, to Çalık Holding, who will build the Samsun-Ceyhan oil pipeline, if the pipeline ever gets built). The same Çalık Holding only paid $150 million of the $1.25 billion for Sabah-ATV media group, which it won as the sole bidder in the privatization tender. The rest of the money came from state banks and a Gulf investment fund. Just so that the government can control one more piece of the media. And for the chunk of media they don't control, they start huge tax investigations.

Now everybody knows about the Deniz Feneri scandal. AKP affiliates, after having founded the charitable foundation of the same name in Turkey in 1998, decided to open one in Germany to tap the resources there - the good-hearted Turkish immigrants. They then proceeded to funnel some of the donations to their own companies, and German affiliates of Islamist media, like Yeni Şafak and Kanal 7, and couriered some of it to Turkey. According to the German indictment, Zahid Akman, the current chairman of the Supreme Board of Radio and Television (RTUK) was an active member of the operation. Akman, who belongs to the same Iskenderpaşa lodge of the Nakşibendi religious brotherhood as Erdogan, remains RTUK chairman.

Ergenekon. The investigation could have been a chance to eliminate criminal elements within the state. It could be the first step of a wholesale effort to bring to justice those responsible for the assassinations of Hrant Dink and Uğur Mumcu, the attack to the Council of State (Danıştay) in 2006, the extra-judicial killings of Kurds in the south east. I am not saying all these crimes were committed by a single organization, but Ergenekon could be the first step in a series of investigations, it could be the first spark. The investigators, however, framed the investigation around the assumption that the whole purpose was to overthrow the government. This gave them the pretext to intimidate and weaken those who oppose the AKP.

A public relations campaign is carried out in pro-government media outlets alongside the investigation. There seems to be an archive of tapped phone conversations and confidential documents, from which the most relevant ones are leaked to pro-government press at opportune times. Law 5397, which was adopted on 3.7.2005, extended the scope of legal phone tapping by allowing police chiefs, gendarmarie commanders and the National Intelligence Organization to issue a phone tapping order, subject to the approval of the judges of Heavy Punishment Courts within 24 hours. These tappings are carried out to “prevent” crimes such as organized drug trafficking and “violent attempts to overthrow the government.” There seems to be no mechanism to supervise these tappings to make sure that they remain confidential.

Given that the AKP's definition of democracy is limited to electoral success, it is no surprise that the government's main priority has been the local elections since the Constitutional Court verdict that saved them from dissolution in July. Erdogan himself picked most of the AKP candidates in the local elections. Within the party, Erdogan is surrounded by a circle of loyal supporters, and he has to have the last word before a piece of legislation is submitted to the parliament. There must be a mountain of law proposals in the "Prime Ministry," which are waiting to get the final seal of approval. Very often a law proposal that made the headlines in newspapers is forgotten after it is lost in the prime minister's office.

For someone who doesn't have a personal interest in Turkey, all this may seem like details. This kind of thing happens in every emerging market, one may say. But I am happy that I am able to care enough to feel angry at this. This is not just any subject matter for me, I actually care about it. And I am deeply disappointed. I thought it would be shame not to speak up about it when I have an opinion about it.

Wednesday, March 11, 2009

What you thought you knew (but didn't actually know) about Turkey - 1

I read an article called "Prospects for a 'torn' Turkey: A secular and unitary future?" by Svante E. Cornell and Halil Magnus Karaveli of the Central Asia-Caucasus Institute, Silk Road Studies Program. Their arguments were very refreshing. They made me realize that most accounts of what's going on in Turkey (especially Western perceptions, including some of my 'received opinions') are hopelessly simplistic. So I decided to note some of their points here in a series of posts.
  • Islamic ascendancy was the "irresistable reclaim by a supposedly essential popular culture of a terrain that had been occupied by an alien secularism imposed from above by the state."

In fact, successive secular governments have accommodated Islam since Turkey became a multi-party democracy in 1950. Under the watch of center-right governments Sunni Islam came to dominate the school system and private schools funded by Islamic fraternities and orders found fertile ground.

Ironically, it was the military rule following the 1980 coup that encouraged Islamist politics as an alternative to radical left. With the ingenious "Turkish-Islamic synthesis," the generals attempted to blend right-wing nationalism and Islam. The "Religious Culture and Ethics" class made its way into elementary school curriculum (and the consitution), clerical high schools expanded and a new Islamic intelligentsia was born. The liberalization of the economy created a new middle class with more conservative values, while simultaneously increasing income disparities in the society, fuelling support for Islamic conservatism.

Just as it is simplistic to claim that the state bureaucracy and military are homogenously secularist, it is also simplistic to think that secularism does not have any popular legitimacy. The 2007 Republican demonstrations displayed the popular secularist sentiment (although now the Ergenekon indictment claims that they were an attempt to overthrow the government and put state security at risk.) Although I don't think the organizers of those demonstrations are particularly bright, the democratic right of the participants to express their views is not less important than that of the Islamist conservatives.

Finally, an inherent deficiency of secularism contributed to its decline. As Şerif Mardin put it, "the republic has not given the question of what is good, right and aesthetic any deeper consideration. That is the deficiency of Kemalism." The authors go on to say: "Kemalism was not unsuccessful because it has been applied with vigor and insensitivity to popularly held beliefs, but because republican ideology remained philosophically arid, insufficienty connected to and fecundated by the heritage of the Enlightenment." This goes back to the state policy of accommodating religion while "appearing" secular.

Next up:

  • The prospects of an Islamic reconciliation with liberal values - how democratic is the AKP?
  • The dynamics of ethnic seperatism, Islamism and neo-nationalism.

Thursday, December 25, 2008

Candles

My dad found out what Hanukkah candles mean, and how the ritual goes. He told me the story, but I didn't find it very cute for some reason. I said I didn't believe in religion because it's a way of dominating people. Finding meaning in common stories and symbols bind people together - so do common enemies. I gave women's rights as an example of a fundamental flaw in religions. If religions were the real thing, they would have pointed to universal truths, truths that stand the test of time.

But then I thought, if God gave us all the right answers, S/he would be insulting our intelligence.

Thursday, December 04, 2008

Greek antiquity, Roman law, the conflict between the Pope and the German Kaiser in the Middle Ages, the Reformation, the Enlightenment, all these that give Europe its specific character. Friedbert Pflüger, CDU

Christianity is understood not so much as a belief system or a theology but as a civilizational idea, political culture and lifestyle. As such, for example, it is believed that the cultural roots of some fundamental secular European values, such as the separation of spiritual and worldly affairs, the separation between the public and the private spheres, the idea of natural rights protecting the individual against the state, and, following Max Weber, the culture of capitalism, all have their roots in Europe's Christian heritage. Hakan Yilmaz, Turkish identity on the road to the EU: basic elements of French and German oppositional discourses, page 298.

We have often witnessed peoples, societies and nations outside the Western world – and I can identify with them easily – succumbing to fears that sometimes lead them to commit stupidities, all because of their fears of humiliation and their sensitivities. I also know that in the West – a world with which I can identify with the same ease – nations and peoples taking an excessive pride in their wealth, and in their having brought us the Renaissance, the Enlightenment, and Modernism, have, from time to time, succumbed to a self-satisfaction that is almost as stupid. Orhan Pamuk, in his Nobel lecture


Laiklik


Peki bu Avrupalıların yaşayıp da bizim yaşamadığımız nedir? Ticaretle zenginleşen, bilimle aydınlanan burjuva sınıfının, artık kendilerini yönetme yetkisini Tanrı'dan aldığını iddia eden aristokrasinin masallarına kanmaması mı? Biz ise kendimiz keşfetmedik bunu. Kitaplardan okuyanlarımız, dışarda görenlerimiz ise herkese anlatmak istediler, ancak bazı şeyler anlatılmakla, çabucak öğrenilmiyor. İnsanların ilerlemesini geri gördükleri şeyleri yasaklayarak sağlayabileceklerini umdular. Hem Avrupalılardan farklı olabilir (çünkü bir ulus devlettik ve Avrupalılar bize düşmandı) hem de onları kendi oyunlarında yenebilirdik. Oysa insanların değerleri, alışkanlıkları halının altına süpürülerek yok olmuyor. İnsanlar sizin anlattığınız hikayeye inanamıyorlar hemen. Kendileri ikna olmaları gerek. Bu da zaman alıyor.

O yüzden mi acaba bizim muhafazakarlarımız, Avrupalıların muhafazakarlarından daha korkutucu? O yüzden mi biz dini değerlerin yaşamlarımıza empoze edilebileceğinden (hatta şimdiden edilmekte olduğundan) korkuyoruz?

Friday, November 28, 2008

Around that track

Long ago, I wrote that people draw their strengths from others' weaknesses. A position of power is only possible if one has subordinates. And usually, these little luxuries are gained after years of hard work. That's why people have little incentives to help newcomers or outsiders. People want to enjoy some exclusivity, because they paid the price for it.


Over the past couple of days, I have been reading about an argument I completely overlooked before. Up to now, I dismissed the argument that Turkey and the European Union are incompatible, because they belong to different value systems. I thought this was fatalistic, I thought it robbed Turkey (and other countries who are admittedly behind) the chance to reform their ways. I thought countries should be allowed to climb the world's civilization ladder if they are willing to do so. It was the only way the EU would have a meaning and future greater than itself, the only way forward. That's why arguments emphasizing the irreconcilable differences in identity and values seemed lazy to me (just like it is lazy for Turkish nationalists to argue that we are too different.) I rallied against the fact that Turkish accession would have to be approved in popular referenda even if it met all accession criteria. Europeans raised hurdles like the Cyprus issue just to discourage Turkey from pursuing membership. They weren't honest, they didn't act in good faith.

After a couple of days' worth of reading, now I see how identities and values matter for European people (like everyone else), and how they may feel like the enlargement process is imposing upon them something they shouldn't have to endure.

Researchers group people's and countries' "attitudes" towards the enlargement issue in three categories. The first one is a rational cost-benefit analysis, where people weigh potential socio-economic and security benefits against potential costs. The second one is identity considerations, where people look at whether Turkey's values are compatible with European values. The third one is "post-nationalism," which permits accession as long as Turkey internalizes the common values the EU is built upon, democracy and human rights being the foremost. In other words, Turkey should be allowed in if it fulfills all the accession criteria.

Member states' attitude towards enlargement is largely determined by the kind of future they envision for the EU, and we go back to the "enlargement" versus "deepening" dichotomy. Countries like the UK and Sweden argue for a loose union. They believe there is no reason to push for commitment where it is too costly. The EU is already quite large, and it unavoidably involves members with different foreign policy and economic interests. They would follow a rational, post-national attitude. Even if irreconcilable differences between value systems exist, they would claim that this is beside the point as long as each member state respects the common values of democracy and human rights.

The right wing in countries like France, Germany and Austria, on the other hand, believes that the EU can be a powerful player only as a stronger political union, and homogeneity is required for it to become one. Here are some voices from this camp, taken from Hakan Yilmaz's article Turkish identity on the road to the EU: basic elements of French and German oppositional discourses (Journal of Southern Europe and the Balkans, December 2007).

"A political union needs something like a we-feeling. This we-feeling is something more than a commitment to democracy and human rights. It has to do with a centuries-old shared history: Greek antiquity, Roman law, the conflict between the Pope and the German Kaiser in the Middle Ages, the Reformation, the Enlightenment, all these that give Europe its specific character." Friedbert Pflüger, CDU

"Christianity is understood not so much as a belief system or a theology but as a civilizational idea, political culture and lifestyle. As such, for example, it is believed that the cultural roots of some fundamental secular European values, such as the separation of spiritual and worldly affairs, the separation between the public and the private spheres, the idea of natural rights protecting the individual against the state, and, following Max Weber, the culture of capitalism, all have their roots in Europe's Christian heritage." Hakan Yilmaz, page 298.

"In principle, a non-Western and non-Christian country like Turkey can adopt Western values, without sharing Christianity and Western history. However, this westernization will take a very long time and it will not be completed in ten to fifteen years. A long time is necessary." Professor Heinrich August Winkler, Humboldt University

"By underestimating the concrete difficulties our societies have to properly integrate Muslims already living in our communities, [if we admit Turkey into the EU] we could in the end be increasing the risk of a 'clash of civilizations' within Europe, instead of avoiding it." Sylvie Goulard.

There is yet another question. Would Turkey's cultural and religious heritage, its history prevent it from internalizing democratic values in the timeframe envisioned for possible accession (10-15 years), tying the hands of even post-nationalist supporters of accession?

"Even the long-standing secular tradition of Muslim Turkey does not make it any more 'integrateable' to Europe, because it is generally believed that Turkish secularism is fake, it is artificial, it has been assimilated by a small Westernized elite, it has not submerged into the 'cultural genes' of the larger Turkish society, and it has been protected only by the force of arms." Hakan Yilmaz

I have to accept that these views are correct in this moment in history. However, they reflect a static view of history, they reflect conservatism. What I call for is not tolerance for values and practices that cannot be tolerated. What I call for is faith in that values and practices that should be reformed can be reformed - in due course. Because idealism is necessary to work for something better. Especially if you don't happen to be a European citizen.

Sunday, November 02, 2008

a theory about why values matter

Yesterday I met up with some friends to discuss things that we are all interested in. One of our friends talked about different value systems, and said that the thing that ties most people to a value system (and not another) is not rational choice, but habit and emotion. He said societies should have serious debates about "morality", what is right and what is wrong. I decided to think through this idea and its implications.

First of all, why is there a need to have a public discussion about moral issues? Because value systems do not stay contained within one individual's life or one clearly-defined group. The value system of a policy maker will bear on his policy choices and affect all groups in the society.

Secondly, what is a "value system"? My definiton of a value is "the best way of doing something or solving a problem" for an individual, and a value system is a network of (ideally) mutually consistent and enforcing values. At the core of all these values is one or more assumptions. The validity of these assumptions is often not tested (or by nature cannot be tested). However, they provide answers to big fundamental questions. The system, then, gives answers to all the smaller questions based on the big answer at the core.

I will give an example from my own value system first. Let's say the question is, "should I drink wine?" My core assumption is that my actions should not harm myself or anyone, because that's bad, useless and troublesome. Then the answer is a simple "yes, but in moderation!" Let's take a devout Muslim. When faced with this question, he will go back to his core assumption: That God is the creator of universe and Hz. Muhammed is His prophet, and the best way to live life is to follow the rules prescribed by the Kur'an. Drinking wine is a sin according to the Kur'an. Moreover, if this person has never seen their family or friends drink wine, he will view a sudden change of habit as betrayal to his heritage. If he breaks one rule, would he lose his anchor, would his life lose its consistence, coherence and meaning?

Now let's see how this person's value system would affect his policy making. He sees people drinking wine in restaurants and bars, and they seem a little too happy and annoying. They might go out and drive and commit indecencies. Even if he realizes that wine drinkers do not harm him directly, he might simply take upon himself to spread the good in the society. Then our policymaker would adopt policies that limit wine drinking.

This theory can be applied to other social issues such as religious rights, abortion, stem cell research, gay marriage and women's rights. More significantly, policymakers may impose their value systems on the youth through the education curriculum and the media. Debates over the teaching of "intelligent design" versus "evolutionary theory" in the US is a good example.

But the remit of value systems is not limited to social issues, and assumptions are not always religious (although they demonstrate "religious" qualities). Economic policy is influenced by its own value systems. For example, neoliberalism was the most popular value system until the most recent crisis. Its core assumption, that market forces will allocate resources more efficiently, and regulation should be minimal, was considered almost as a law of nature by its proponents. The latest crisis demonstrated that this assumption was not tested in all circumstances. Communism was its own value system, and it didn't stand the test of time.

Another example can be national security and freedoms. Civil servants in Turkey, for example, typically belong to one value system. The core assumption of this system is that "the unity of the Turkish territory and nation should be protected against divisive ethnic and religious forces at all cost". Now, the validity and effectiveness of this assumption is open to question, but because of it, national security takes precedence over individual freedoms.

Having blind faith in the truth of a value system may be comfortable, but what if your assumptions are wrong? What if there are better options out there? What if evolution makes more sense than intelligent design (or visa versa)? Wouldn't we be closing ourselves to other possibilities, turning a blind eye on lessons learned from experience and research, limiting our potential for growth?

What matters is what you learn after you know it all.

In some areas, a society of free-thinking individuals would converge to value systems whose truth stands the test of time. In other instances, it may decide that some issues are personal, and the society should have no bearing on an individual's choice. But we should be open to listening to each other and changing our minds, however difficult and disconcerting it is. This is the only way forward.

Thursday, June 12, 2008

"Got an earful from the aunt. But it was Quoyle who smoothed things out, explained in a reasonable voice, coaxed the principal and Bunny into mutual apologies and promises. Easy enough for the principal who knew that Mrs. Lumbull was moving to Grand Falls to open a Christian bookstore. Hard for Bunny who still measured events on a child's scale of fair and unfair." The Shipping News, pg. 317

Gray

When we were in Edinburgh, we watched a college movie on the hotel TV, funny enough. There was a big sister and her freshman brother who tried to go into the most popular frat. She was dating this really popular guy, and when he cheated on her, she cheated on him and stayed together with him. When her amazed brother asked why she acted like that, she said: "Black and white - that was in high school. Now we are in the gray zone in between. I can't give up what I've worked so hard for!"

As I'm faced with real life situations, I observe people acting in unprincipled, inconsistent ways that often don't make sense to me. But then I realize, they act like that because they see the big picture, they see what's beyond that situation, rightly so since that situation is not isolated. Sometimes acting "right" in every instance does not yield the right result. People give up something small, some small piece of principle, a sense of what's "right", what's just, what's consistent, to save, to achieve something bigger. They apologize for something they shouldn't apologize for to save someone's face. They don't apologize for what they should apologize for to avoid taking responsibility. We all become diplomats, we all mind balances and act strategically.

This is something new to me. I think it'll help me understand people and the world, and navigate through, though, so that I don't get so stupidly surprised every time someone deviates from best practice!

Input and output legitimacy: Sometimes we have to do the more counter-intuitive, less than ideal thing to achieve the desired outcome.

It's important to set the goals and priorities right, though. You don't want to give up something valuable for something petty. And I still think some things (should) have more value than others. That is (should be) black and white.


...
By the way, it's been a year since I did those LSE exams! I still remember the barbecue on that grassy courtyard with keys, and how the sun came out...

Wednesday, December 05, 2007

From the Times Style supplement, Dec. 2, 2007:

http://women.timesonline.co.uk/tol/life_and_style/women/families/article2941341.ece



Age of innocence?


Shane Watson

Babies, according to new research, can tell good people from bad at the tender age of six months. In tests, the babies unanimously preferred a “positive” doll over both a “negative” or “neutral” doll. In other words, before we can speak, we can distinguish the people who have our best interests at heart. This is pretty amazing when you think about it: not that babies are programmed from birth, but that we all start out with a foolproof people-radar that is then systematically dismantled.

It starts with your parents making you play with their friends’ dysfunctional children. That’s when you learn that you must get on with everyone, even the ones who hit you over the head continuously, for the sake of avoiding awkwardness. The same way you have to put up with your grandparents’ lethal driving and the au pair taking you to the park with her friend and then abandoning you while they smoke. You are too young to point out that these people are not acting in your best interests. But you are learning that in the grown-up world nobody listens to their instincts because they have other more pressing concerns (saving time, saving face, getting through).

Then there’s school. You are a sneak if you tell anyone that the girl in your class is torturing you at break. You are dead if you don’t pick the pretty but unsporty girls first for the rounders team. You must quickly bury your instinctive grasp of who is decent and who is not because the only issue is fitting in.

This distorted perspective becomes normal and, once you hit puberty, the thoughtful boys and girls are toast: both sexes are now only interested in destructive types. Your mother, who has spent the past 15 or so years bludgeoning your instincts into a socially acceptable compromise, starts saying, “Can’t you see he’s no good for you?” Too late! Meanwhile, your brother is definitely a negative doll in your life, as is your mother’s shopaholic best friend, your youth-envying aunt and the neighbour who always gets your dad drunk - all natural enemies. But nobody does anything about it; instead everybody blames you for being too “black and white”.

It gets worse, obviously. All around you there are examples of people who are either negative or nimby or both: so-called friends who moan that you are horrible since you got a boyfriend/lost weight, and so-called colleagues who advertise all the great ideas you have missed during meetings. Gradually your “negative influence” radar gets furred up, because it’s hardly ever appropriate to act on it. When accepting a proposal of marriage, yes. When going into business with someone, yes. But, for some reason, you are not able to say, “I will not have dinner with them because I sense they would use me for a float in a tsunami.” You must throw your inner baby out with the bath water, and just get over yourself.

Monday, May 28, 2007

"Morality: Morality is a way to stop players from playing the best strategy for themselves. Morality persuades the players to cooperate by increasing the costs from cheating. These costs take the form of "reputation costs". You try to be a nice friend, a loyal wife, devoted mother, or honest business partner, in order to avoid these reputation costs. Playing another strategy would have been more profitable without these reputation costs," taken from Miscallenous Lessons of Life.


Water

Deepa Mehta's Water is a beautiful movie. It's about how religious rules and interpretations, purely based on practical reasons, become an instrument of abuse and subordination. They are accepted (or largely overlooked) not only by those who are favoured or remain unaffected, but also by the victims. The mere existence of the rule is supposedly enough to justify their undeserved suffering. The rule cannot be questioned or falsified, after all, it is to be believed in unconditionally. The cost of questioning or breaking the rule is to be reborn as a jackal.

The afterlife (or the role played by chance in this life, and everybody's vulnerability to bad luck) is nothing but a switch from an unrepeated game to a repeated one. Justice will be done: players will be rewarded for their submission and punished for their diversion.

Some rules do have a point, they are based on lessons taken from experience. They are there for a reason, you run the risk of hurting yourself or someone else if you break that rule. Unfortunately not everyone is responsible or thoughtful enough to be decent people without the fear of a penalty being imposed on them. (Here I must point out the importance of information exchange -gossip, that is!- in giving people a bad name!)

But some rules are just non-sense, no matter how hard people try to justify them. The mere existence of a rule is not enough for it to be meaningful. If a rule doesn't make sense to me, if it won't make me or someone else better off, I won't follow it. If it's not there to help me, then it is there to oppress me.

But then, I have a choice. A critical mind, however necessary, is not always enough to stand up against a rule. The costs are too high: Disapproval and even exclusion from one's family and community. Emotions tied to memory, home and tradition are strong.

I tried to explain in the Eye and Paternalism and Tolerance that simply telling people that their beliefs are wrong and backward will not convince them. They have to decide for themselves. Hence I'm against a headscarf ban in universities and public service. But I have to qualify that argument now, because I realize that some younger girls don't really have the choice. A headscarf ban for younger students would be in order to give them the time and freedom to make up their minds. The same argument justifies state intervention to make sure that young girls are sent to school.