The struggle of man against power is the struggle of memory against forgetting. Milan Kundera.
Sunday, January 04, 2015
Brave new world
In this civilization, people, objects and the pleasure you derive from them have no meaning beyond themselves.
There is a reservation where civilization hasn't reached; you can think of it as a crowded, filthy, smelly underdeveloped country. A young man from there, the Savage, who has grown up with a mother, local religious teachings and Shakespeare, is "conditioned" entirely differently. He has strong moral values, more refined tastes and attachments; he values solitude and hard work and suffering as a welcome price to pay for meaning and real happiness. When he is taken to the brave new world for an "experiment," he becomes miserable.
The civilization described in the Brave new world has some parallels with our lives: a stronger resemblence to the lifestyle of the 20- and 30-somethings in western societies, but if we just take the distinction between superficial and deeper happiness as the main point of the book, then it applies to vast populations who seek happiness (or at least, distraction) in shopping and cheap entertainment (including social media and messaging). The display of strong emotions are discouraged at work and at home, and people are advised not to become too invested in anyone or anything lest one develops strong emotions. People remain detached even from their children, who are raised by nannies.
But I agree with the Savage that there is a deeper kind of happiness, which can only be achieved through hard work and time invested in something or someone. You don't know what it feels like until you put in the time and the effort, so it is easy to underestimate it. This is because you don't know how it is to understand or discover something as you do research and write, you don't know how it is to come across a beautiful passage in a long book or feel really connected with a friend, your husband or your child. And you don't know when or if you'll ever feel like that. You'll only know once you put in the time and the effort, when you are already too invested, when you've already developed strong emotions.
Saturday, October 26, 2013
In praise of emotions at work
Saturday, June 12, 2010
Geçen hafta bir arkadaşımız Etyen Mahçupyan'ın şu makalesini yollamış. Okuyunca beni yine bir panik almasın mı... Bir kaç yüz yıl sonra insanlar dönüp bize baktıklarında, çok saçma olduğu çoktan anlaşılmış hurafelere inanan bir sürü sersem görecekler. Kendilerinin ulaştığı bilince ulaşılabilmesi için geçilmesi gereken bir aşama, o aşamanın kurbanları. Yani Russell Crowe filmlerindeki maşrapalardan içki içen, etraflarında dolanan dağınık beyaz tombul kızların memelerini avuçlayan barbar Orta Çağ savaşçıları gibi. (Gerçi bu türden şu anda da pek çok var etrafta, üstelik savaşçı da olmadıkları için iyice can sıkıcılar.) Aptallığımıza acımaya gelinceye kadar, herhalde serbest piyasa hurafesine inanıp başlarına bir sürü borç bıraktığımız için zaten öfkeli olacaklar bize. Aman canım ne yapalım. Biz de gelecek nesilleri böyle uzaylı gibi canlandırmıyor muyuz gözümüzde.
Misal ben, bir türlü post-modern olmayı başaramıyorum. Neymiş efendim, mutlak doğrulara "just because" inanıp, her kararımızı onlara dayandırmayacak, onlarla kısıtlamayacakmışız. Her şeyle aramızda ironik bir mesafe olacakmış ki, inançlarımız bizi yönetmesin, biz inançlarımızı yönetelim. Yani ne dine inanalım, ne kendimizi bir yere ait hissedelim, ne ailemize bir sorumluluğumuz olsun, ne de çok değerli bilim adamlarının teorilerine körü körüne bağlanalım. Otoritelerin bilmemize izin verdiği kadarına elimiz mahkum olabilir, ama komplo teorileri kurabiliriz dilediğimizce.
Tamam öyle olsun da, böyle yüzüp yüzüp kuyruğuna geliyorum, tam post-modern olacağım, kendimle yüz yüze geleceğim, kararlarımın tek sahibi, tek dayanağı ben olacağım... Kendime bir bakıyorum, kaçtığım her şeyin toplamı gibiyim. Kendim burdayım ama işim, ilgilerim, sevdiklerim Türkiye'yle ilgili. Şimdi bunları özgür irademle seçersem post-modern sayılabilir miyim? Yani böyle özgürce türban takmış gibi falan? Çok kafam karışık, çok.
Tuesday, June 01, 2010
Like a bug in a jar of thick honey. What to do to get out and fly again in the cool, light breeze of rationality? What to do to find my balance? Should I keep myself occupied - with work, friends, football games, electronic gadgets, traveling, soap operas, shopping, consumption of art and news and analysis and gossip? Should I start drinking?
We are drugging ourselves with constant activity not to allow any second, unhappy, unsure thoughts into our heads. Because these thoughts spark unnerving emotions. Guilt, regret, despair at the missed chances. We do our best to distract ourselves constantly from what really matters in the world and in our lives. So that we won't have to do anything about it. So that we have the strength to live with what we never try to understand or express or change.
Sometimes I wonder who will be remembered a hundred years from now as the great thinkers, writers and artists of our times. Do we have them amongst us? Have we heard of them already? I'm afraid they may be too distracted to produce real stuff, stuff that captures the spirit of our times and lives. I'm afraid we may be too busy to leave anything meaningful behind.
Monday, April 20, 2009
First, the reason I have been away for a while: I was working on a longer piece. Since I started keeping this blog, I have had the feeling that I should put everything I write here for the sake of completeness. It's hard to get over this self-imposed obligation. But that piece is too long, so I will keep it to myself for the time being. But of course, it's just a step along the way. There will be a next step, which is this post.
But then I thought, my previous post was the perfect ending to this blog. "There's no happy ending - mutlu son yok." The only child wakes up to the reality that life is not easy, and it's not enough to do less than what she needs to do just because. She's not entitled to anything more than everyone else. The purpose of the stars and people is not to align themselves so as to make her wishes come true there and then. Sometimes she should align herself. Sulking because "this or that should have been easier" doesn't make it easier. Actually, taking good care of and nurturing anything takes hard work. And nobody is an exception. And so I thought, I have matured a little bit since I've started writing here. This is a good point to end.
But then, there's no happy ending and no absolute wisdom. I keep getting new ideas. For example, I've had this dream where I actually remember saying to myself, "these are two really good ideas, I should write them!" In the dream I was sure I would remember them, but of course I don't remember them. Maybe all they were was the happy dream, the idea of a good idea. Then this morning I came up with a new idea but then completely forgot about it.
And I keep seeing new examples of what I've written about before. At first, out of laziness disguised by a noble sense of originality, I say: "I've written about this before, I shouldn't repeat myself!" But the injustice is going on. As long as the injustice is going on, we shouldn't content ourselves with having said something once. We should say the truth, we should speak our minds as many times as the truth is overlooked and the justice is violated, at the expense of repeating ourselves and boring people. It's the obligation of those who are aware.
This story I wrote. It's more a diary than a story. Again, out of laziness disguised by a noble sense of sincerity, I haven't been able to write any fiction so far. I say to myself, I am not able to feel strongly (the emotional energy mentioned in the Golden Notebook) about anything that doesn't personally touch me. So I consider myself unable to imagine what someone else could be going through, feeling, imagining worlds. I feel like truth and sincerity would escape me if I were to talk about someone else, I could never forget myself.
Performing vs. feeling. In What Philosophers Think, one of the philosophers made this distinction. Being too aware of your feelings drains the truth out of them. The philosopher there gave the example of becoming aware that you are feeling sorry for someone, and then thinking, "how noble of me to feel sorry!" This isn't putting yourself in that person's shoes and genuinely feeling sorry for them. This is staying squarely in your own shoes.
If you are doing something, if you are somewhere, when your heart is somewhere else, you are actively and consciously performing. Sometimes when the plane lands you hear the voice of the flight attendant, and it sounds more like a performance than someone really speaking. (Or you get the impression that a voice that exudes that much self-importance cannot be real. She must be kidding us!)
You get the point. I'm afraid of this performing seeping into and infecting what I write. Pretending I care about something when in fact I only like the idea of caring about it, I like being that kind of person, who cares about such things. That would be forcing it. I don't want to force anything. So far I've only gotten feelings and ideas out of the world. Will I be able to create worlds out of feelings and ideas? Go from someone feeling sorry for someone suffering to someone understanding and feeling what suffering is like? Maybe I don't have what it takes, and I should suck it up.
Anyway, as I was thinking about these things, I came across J.K. Rowling's Commencement Speech at Harvard University. (The things I get out of people's profiles in the Facebook! Social networking will speed up the development of humankind.) She says:
Imagination is not only the uniquely human capacity to envision that which is not, and therefore the fount of all invention and innovation. In its arguably most transformative and revelatory capacity, it is the power that enables us to empathise with humans whose experiences we have never shared.
One of the greatest formative experiences of my life preceded Harry Potter, though it informed much of what I subsequently wrote in those books. This revelation came in the form of one of my earliest day jobs. Though I was sloping off to write stories during my lunch hours, I paid the rent in my early 20s by working at the African research department at Amnesty International’s headquarters in London.
There in my little office I read hastily scribbled letters smuggled out of totalitarian regimes by men and women who were risking imprisonment to inform the outside world of what was happening to them. I saw photographs of those who had disappeared without trace, sent to Amnesty by their desperate families and friends. I read the testimony of torture victims and saw pictures of their injuries. I opened handwritten, eye-witness accounts of summary trials and executions, of kidnappings and rapes.
Many of my co-workers were ex-political prisoners, people who had been displaced from their homes, or fled into exile, because they had the temerity to speak against their governments. Visitors to our offices included those who had come to give information, or to try and find out what had happened to those they had left behind.
I shall never forget the African torture victim, a young man no older than I was at the time, who had become mentally ill after all he had endured in his homeland. He trembled uncontrollably as he spoke into a video camera about the brutality inflicted upon him. He was a foot taller than I was, and seemed as fragile as a child. I was given the job of escorting him back to the Underground Station afterwards, and this man whose life had been shattered by cruelty took my hand with exquisite courtesy, and wished me future happiness.
And as long as I live I shall remember walking along an empty corridor and suddenly hearing, from behind a closed door, a scream of pain and horror such as I have never heard since. The door opened, and the researcher poked out her head and told me to run and make a hot drink for the young man sitting with her. She had just had to give him the news that in retaliation for his own outspokenness against his country’s regime, his mother had been seized and executed.
Every day of my working week in my early 20s I was reminded how incredibly fortunate I was, to live in a country with a democratically elected government, where legal representation and a public trial were the rights of everyone.
Every day, I saw more evidence about the evils humankind will inflict on their fellow humans, to gain or maintain power. I began to have nightmares, literal nightmares, about some of the things I saw, heard, and read.
And yet I also learned more about human goodness at Amnesty International than I had ever known before.
Amnesty mobilises thousands of people who have never been tortured or imprisoned for their beliefs to act on behalf of those who have. The power of human empathy, leading to collective action, saves lives, and frees prisoners. Ordinary people, whose personal well-being and security are assured, join together in huge numbers to save people they do not know, and will never meet. My small participation in that process was one of the most humbling and inspiring experiences of my life.
Unlike any other creature on this planet, humans can learn and understand, without having experienced. They can think themselves into other people’s places.
Of course, this is a power, like my brand of fictional magic, that is morally neutral. One might use such an ability to manipulate, or control, just as much as to understand or sympathise.
And many prefer not to exercise their imaginations at all. They choose to remain comfortably within the bounds of their own experience, never troubling to wonder how it would feel to have been born other than they are. They can refuse to hear screams or to peer inside cages; they can close their minds and hearts to any suffering that does not touch them personally; they can refuse to know.
I have been reading a lot about Pınar Selek in Radikal lately. She is a Turkish sociologist who tried to imagine when she could have had a very comfortable, respectable life had she chosen to look over these things. She imagined what it would be like to be a transvestite, a child living on the streets, a young boy (or older boy) doing his military service, and a member of the Kurdistan Workers' Party (PKK). She advocated pacifism and women's rights. She put her money where her mouth is and talked to these people, lived with them. She tried to grasp their truth.
Because of her stance, her attitude, because of her choosing to be who she is rather than denying herself, she was accused of being involved in a 1998 explosion in the Spice Bazaar in Istanbul. After spending two and a half years in jail she was acquitted, but the Supreme Court of Appeals overturned this decision. To this day it is not clear whether the explosion was due to a LPG container or a bomb, but now she's being charged again. The prosecutor demands a life sentence. Radikal columnist Yıldırım Türker writes on 13 April:
Pınar Selek’le bir keresinde hapishaneden çıktığında buluşmuştuk. O sıralar 29 yaşındaydı. Hayalî bombacı olarak iki buçuk yılını Ümraniye Cezaevi’nde geçirmiş, kanlı bir ‘Hayata Dönüş’ operasyonu ertesi tahliye edilmişti. Çok şey görmüş, çok yaradan yaralanmıştı. Ama kendi olma, kendi kalma mücadelesini sürdürmeye yeminliydi.
Güneşli bir sabah Pınar Selek’le iki ajan gibi buluştuğumuzu hatırlıyorum. Ardındaki gazeteci ve diğer meraklıları atlatarak randevu yerine geldi. Kendimize bir sığınak bulup uzun uzun konuştuk. Beni en çok şaşırtan, hiç acılaşmamış olmasıydı. Coşkusundan, iyi bir dünyalı olma hevesinden hiçbir şey kaybetmemişti. İnsana şu dünyada durduğu yeri zindan ediveren içtenliği hiç yara almamıştı. Önce ondan sonra kendinizden kuşku duyar hale geliyor, bu gencecik insanın inceliği, yumuşaklığı, sevecenliği karşısında kilitlenip kalıyordunuz. Kendi hakkında bir şey anlatırken mahçup olan, tutuklandığında yaşadığı işkenceden bahsetmeyi uygun bulmayan, mağduriyet dilinin refahına bir an olsun sığınmayan Pınar, kendini mümkünse unutturmak istiyordu. Kahramanlığa, önde durmaya yatkın değildi, dünyayla yüzleşme yordamı.
Yıllar önce daha gencecik bir kızken sokak çocuklarının arasında onlardan biri olarak dünyaya tutunma çabasına tanık olmuştum. Sonra Ülker sokaktan üstlerine şanlı bayraklar sallanarak kovulan travestilerle birlikte, aynı kuytuda sabahladığına tanık olmuştum.
Pınar Selek hakkındaki duygularım hiç değişmedi.
Militarist vahşilerinki de.
Onlar, bu genç kadının bombalardan daha güçlü olduğunu erken fark ettiler.
Her acıdan, her zulümden yüzünde aynı ışıklı gülümseme, aynı tevazuuyla çıkışı besbelli onları deli etti. Onu benzetemediler. Pınar, etrafına mutluluk ve güç saçarak kendi seçmiş olduğu hayatı, kendi seçmiş olduğu hayatın müttefikleriyle birlikte sürdürüyor çünkü.
Kadının özgürleşmesinden, heteroseksizme karşı direnmekten, barışın önemli bir tetikleyicisi olan vicdani redden dem vuruyor çünkü. ‘Barışamadık’ kitabının bir bölümüne epigraf olarak Gandhi’nin bir sözünü koymuş: “Barışçıl mücadelede en ufak bir kuşku başarısızlık için yeterlidir. Sonuna kadar başarılı olmanın yolu saflık ve dürüstlüktür.”
Onun yıllarını çalan, işkencecileri üstüne salıp canını yakan, anasını alan, hayatı ona zehretmeye çalışanlara rağmen hep saf ve dürüst kaldı."
Recently I stepped out of Waitrose with bags in my hand. A dark lady, with dark hair and eyes (saçları, gözü kara) caught my eye. She stopped me and started explaining her cause, she was a member of the Iran Liberty Association. Apparently Iran is putting pressure on Iraq to return the residents of Camp Ashraf, who are members of the Iranian opposition party. I tried to escape, I have never made a donation on the street before. She said her brother was killed, and she had the choice between going on with her life in the US, where her daughter is, and coming to the UK to take part in this campaign. "We all come to this world for a reason," she said. I said I didn't know whether my contribution would be going towards a good cause, and she said she "wouldn't be standing there for 10 hours every day if she didn't believe that it was." Maybe it was a mistake I donated without doing due diligence of who is right. Maybe it is not possible to know who is right. A few days later I received a receipt by post, as she had promised.
Today a Tamil group was protesting in front of the US Embassy. During our two-hour wait we listened to them chanting "Obama-Obama" and their drum beat.
I might have been annoyed had they been a Kurdish group protesting against Turkey.
But we should all work on our imaginations to grasp the truth.
Sunday, January 18, 2009
slow
The pilot I spoke of in the previous post. Don't misunderstand me. I spent hours watching survivors' and witnesses' accounts of him landing on the Hudson (and I didn't like watching Gazan hospitals, so the criticism was directed at myself). I admire this guy so much. I'm pretty sure I wouldn't be able to be so quick and decisive if I were in his place (and even with his experience!).
Yesterday I went to watch Slumdog Millionaire with a good friend of mine in Haymarket Cineworld. We didn't have assigned seats, so people sat wherever they found. A couple (with huge muscles) sat in front of us. I think muscle volume takes away from brains, and soon I was proven right. A guy who was clearly sick and had difficulty walking stopped by their row, asking if he could take the seat next to the couple. This asshole's precious backpack occupied the seat, and he pointed at the seat right in front, asking "what's wrong with this one?" The guy said he had neck problems. Frowning and hissing, the asshole finally moved to move his backpack, but by then the sick guy said, "Don't worry, I'll find another seat," and climbed back the stairs. My friend and I were shocked, the asshole's other half was clearly embarassed, looking back to see where the guy went. And although I was the closest bystander, I didn't do anything. A moment later I thought, "I should have given him my seat and move next to this asshole, obliging him to sit with his backpack on his lap!" But it was too late. I played the scene in my head over and over, how I would spare the sick guy the trouble of finding another seat, how I would face down the asshole and ask kindly but firmly, "Sir, have you paid for this seat?" Then I briefly thought to clear myself, "but the sick guy should have gotten a disabled seat!" We need regulations to protect the weak from assholes, right?
But I didn't do anything, and the moment passed. One of the indications of a person's value is how they react to a situation in very short notice. Of course experience helps, but if you pass your chance, another moment may never come again. And I really think we shouldn't let assholes like this prevail if we have any respect for ourselves.
Tuesday, December 30, 2008
"How to Protect Human Dignity from Science," Daniel C. Dennett, March 2008.
Ruhlar ve makineler
Lisedeyken okuduğum Sofi'nin Dünyası'nda hiç unutamadığım bir cümle var. "Eğer beynimiz bizim anlayabileceğimiz kadar basit olsaydı, bizim onu anlayamayacak kadar aptal olmamız gerekirdi." Dün Newsweek Türkiye'nin eski bir sayısında korku, öfke, aşk, mutluluk ve inanç gibi "duygu"ların beynin hangi bölümlerinde oluştuğunu açıklayan bir yazı okudum. Yazının başında haklı olarak şu soru soruluyordu: Acaba duygularımızın, tepkilerimizin ve başarısızlıklarımızın biyolojik açıklamalarını öğrenmek, bunları değiştiremeyeceğimizi düşünmemize yol açar, bizi ahlaki tembelliğe iter mi? Dergi şöyle cevap veriyor:
"Aslında gerçekten her şeyi bize beynimiz yaptırıyor. Ama yine de bunun anlamlı hayatlar yaşamamız ve ahlaki seçimler yapmamızla ilgili tutarlı bir yanı var. Bu yılın başında filozof Daniel Dennett, ABD Başkanlık Biyoetik Konseyi için hazırladığı bir yazıda, zihinsel hayatımızın biyolojisiyle ilgili bilgi sahibi olmanın bize avantaj sağlayacağını söylüyor. Filozofa göre, bu durum karar alma mekanizmalarımızı ve hatta ahlâki kararlarımızı bile geliştirebilir. Dennett, böylece insan türünün hayatta kalma şansının da artacağını belirtiyor."
Tabii bu yanıtın içini doldurmak için öncelikle Dennett'ın yazısını okumak gerekiyor. Arada sırada yaşadığım ve beni şaşırtan tecrübe ise şu: Beni mantıksız, "anormal" davranmaya iten bir duyguyu yaşarken bunun biyolojik nedenleri olduğunu sezmek, ancak yine de o duygudan kurtulamamak. Örneğin yorgunluğun getirdiği sabırsızlık ve alınganlık ya da kahve içtiğimde hissettiğim iyimserlik ve enerji. Bazı günler işlere kolayca yoğunlaşabilirken, enerji doluyken, bazı günler kapıldığım anlamsızlık hissi.
Birinci elden yaşadığımız bu tecrübeler, kaçınılmaz olarak akla şu soruları getiriyor: Duygu, düşünce ve davranışlarımızın ne kadarı bizim kontrolümüzde? Biz ne kadar özgürüz, seçimlerimiz ne kadar anlamlı? Yetenek ve başarılarımızın ne kadarı sahiden bizim? Uyuşturucu etkisi altındayken bir sanat eseri yaratan sanatçı, o eserin üzerinde ne kadar hak iddia edebilir? Bir suçlunun akli dengesinin yerinde olup olmadığı, bir suçu "bilerek ve isteyerek" işleyip işlemediği, bir kurbanın ruhsal sağlığının bozulup bozulmadığı hangi kriterlere göre belirlenebilir? Yapışık ikizler, beyninin içinde ikizinin ayağını taşıyan çocuk, "hamile erkek" gibi "anomalilerin" farkında olmak, insan hayatının anlamı, değeri ve ona bu anlamı veren varsayımlarımız hakkında şüpheye düşmemize yol açıyor. İnsan hayatını çevreleyen anlam halesi ve ahlaki tabular ortadan kalktığında ise, vücutlarımız değeri belirlenebilir birer "ürün" (commodity) haline gelmiyor mu?
Dennett'ın yazısı gerçekten çok ilginç. Bilimin "açıklayabildiği" her yeni şey, eski inançlarımızı sorgulamamıza yol açıyor. İnanç sistemimizdeki her değişiklik ise, toplumsal ve kişisel hayatımızda büyük ve geri dönülmez değişimleri beraberinde getiriyor. Dennett, yatırımcıların beklentileri değiştiği için birden bire değeri düşen bir para birimini, hak-hukuk ve güvenlik sağlaması beklenmediği için iflas eden bir devleti, ya da bir kasabanın birden kendilerini tehlikede gördükleri için kapılarını kilitlemeye başlayan sakinlerini örnek gösteriyor. Ona göre, bilimin açıklamaları ışığında birden her davranışımızı biyolojik nedenlere bağlamamız, inanç sistemlerimizde tehlikeli değişimlere yol açabilir.
Dennett, inanç sistemimizin bazı yönlerini, bilimin getirdiği şüpheciliğe karşı korumamız gerektiğini düşünüyor. Bunu tutarlı bir şekilde yapmanın yolu da, inançlarımızın gerçeklere dayandığını, doğruluklarının kanıtlanabileceğini iddia etmektense (çünkü bilimin ortaya çıkardığı gerçekler karşısında bu iddiaların ikna kabiliyeti azaldı), inançlarımızın ve değerlerimizin sonuçlarına bakmaktan geçiyor. (Hatice'ye değil neticeye bak.) Burada Dennett, ehliyet alma yaşını örnek gösteriyor. Herkesin on altı ya da on sekiz yaşında araba kullanmaya hazır olduğunu bilimsel olarak kanıtlayamayacağımız gibi, insanların araba kullanmaya hazır hale gelebilmesi için geçmesi gereken belirli bir olgunluk eşiğinin varolduğunu bile iddia edemeyiz. Ancak ehliyet alma yaşı toplumdaki bir belirsizliği giderir ve trafiğin güvenliğini artırır. Ehliyet yaşının "bilimsel" olarak tamamen mantıklı olup olmadığını tartışmaya açmak, zaman ve enerji kaybından başka bir işe yaramaz.
Dennett'a göre, geleceğe dair beklenti oluşturabilmek ve plan yapabilmek için, herkesin kabul ettiği inanç ve değerlere sahip olmamız gerekiyor. Örneğin demokratik rejimlerin devam edeceğini varsayabilmek için, demokratik rejimlerin Churchill'in dediği gibi alternatiflerinden daha iyi olduğuna inanmamız gerekir. Para biriktirebilmek için paranın değerinin düşmeyeceğine, yatırım yapmak için hukuk düzeninin doğruluğuna ve değişmezliğine inanmak zorundayız.
Filozof, bu değer ve inançların varlığını sürdürebilmek için bazen kendi kendimize yalan söylemek zorunda olduğumuzu kabul ediyor. Burada psikiyatrist George Anslie'nin Breakdown of Will (İradenin Çöküşü) kitabından alıntılar yapıyor. Bu değer ve inançları kaybetmemek adına gerçeği arama ve gerçeği gösterme güdümüze ters düşen şeyler yapıyoruz, gerçeği bazen görmezden geliyoruz. Buna örnek olarak ise, Dennett etnik eşitliğe inancı korumak adına, değişik ırklara mensup kişilerin biyolojik farklılıklarına ilişkin yararlı sonuçlar doğurabilecek araştırmaların görmezden gelinmesini gösteriyor.
"İnançların stratejik korunması"nın hayatımızda yakından bildiğimiz pek çok örneği var. Dennett'in Anslie'nin kitabından alıntıladığı bu bölümü tam olarak çevirmezsem olmaz:
"Hesaplayarak ya da ondan bir medet umarak gösterdiğimizde mahvolan çabanın değerli kalmasını istiyorsak, hilebazlıktan vazgeçmemeliyiz. Örneğin, seks ya da 'sevilmek' için gösterilen romantizm, para için yaptığımız mesleğimiz, insanlardaki etkisini görmek için yapılan bir sanat performansı kabalık olarak görülür. Seks, sevgi, para ya da alkışın motive edici etkisinin çok fazla farkında olmak gösterilen çabayı mahveder, üstelik sırf etrafımızdaki insanların gözünü açtığı için değil. Çabalarımızın asıl kıymetiyle ilgili inançlarımız, bu inançların doğruluğundan daha değerlidir, çünkü bu inançlar gerekli olan hilebazlığı sağlar."
Ne için gerekli olan? Gösterilen çabanın, ortaya çıkan ürünün değerli olması için gerekli olan. Yani ortaya çıkan ürünün gerçekten değerli olmasını istiyorsak, onu hesapsızca, saflıkla, samimiyetle, "onun için ve yalnızca onun için" yaptığımıza önce kendi kendimizi inandırmamız gerekir. Yani saf olmasak da bir an için saflığı yakalamak, kendimizi saf sanmak. İnançlarımızı korurken de, onlara gerçekten inanabilmek istiyorsak, şüphelerimizi unutmak zorundayız. Yani bazen en mantıklısı mantığı elden bırakmak.
Monday, September 29, 2008
Zaman izafi midir?
Fizik dersinde berbattım. En arkada oturup başka şeylerle vakti ‘öldürmeye’ çalışırdım. Öyle zor geçerdi ki fizik dersinde zaman. Açıp açık açık kitabını da okuyamazsın. Yani dersi dinler havasını yaratarak, ne yapılabilirse, öyle geçirmeye çabalamak zamanı... Şimdi bile aşırı sıkıntıyla geçirdiğim zamanları ‘fizik dersi gibi’ diye tasvir ederim.
Oysa gerçekten, samimi olarak, fizikten anlayabilen bir kafam olsun isterdim. O formüller, akselerasyon mesela: Hem gerçekte olagelen şeyler, hem de onca soyutlanarak bir formül halinde -yani bir hap gibi- sana sunuluyorlar. Taş düşüyor işte, işte eğim var, taşın hızı var, hepsini simgeleyen bir işaret var. Sen de yapacaksın hesabını, ama ne önemi var? Gerçi böyle felsefi nedenlerle direnmiyordum fiziğe. İşin içinden çıkamıyordum. Gerçek anlamda kafam basmıyordu işte. Einstein’ın o muhteşem, enerji eşittir formülü. Sonra nasıl Freud sayesinde bilinçaltı ve bilinçdışı olduğunu biliyorsak, Einstein sayesinde zamanın izafi olduğunu biliyoruz.
Zamanın izafi olduğu zamanlar vardı. Kapı çalınırdı. Bir arkadaş sana gelirdi. Sonra bir 24, 36 saat kayıp giderdi. Muhtelif yerlerde yenilir, sokaklarda yürünür, videoda filmler izlenir ve kimseye hiçbir şeyin hesabı verilmezdi. Öle bir durum yoktu. Hesap vermeyi gerektiren bir durum yani. Bir arkadaşın arka odasına kapanılıp üç gün hiç çıkmadan -tabii yemek, içmek ve tuvalet dışında- Shibumi okunabilirdi, diyelim. O zamanlar, yani gençken, zaman izafiydi.
Zaman, içine girilip gönlünce yüzülen bir okyanustu. Rüya görmeye vakit vardı örneğin. Bol bol rüya görülür, onlar hatırlanır, anlatılırdı. Oysa dilediğinizce uyuma hakkı elinizden alındığında rüya da göremez, daha doğrusu gördüğünüz rüyaları hatırlayamazsınız. Zaman, bir hapishane çizelgesine dönüşür. Her saat halletmeniz gereken kalemler, bunlardan kaytarmaya cüret edecekseniz, kendi kendinize vermeniz gereken hesaplar vardır: Dolusunuzdur. Da neyle? Bir sürü hamaliye saçmalıkla. Her gün, listelerle sona erer. Her gün, atlamanız gereken bir sürü engelle donanmış bir koşudur. Siz de iyi eğitilmiş ve yarışmak dışında hiçbir şeye hakkı olmadığını iliklerine kadar hisseden bir yarış atı.
Mekanik bir at üstelik. Her türlü haz duygusundan tasarlanırken muaf tutulmuş. Bazen yangından mal kaçırır gibi, biraz zaman araklamaya kalkarsınız işten güçten. Ne acıklı bir çaba! Bunu faiziyle ödemeniz gerektiğini bilmek, o soluk soluğalık ‘araklanan’ zamanı baştan lekeler. Mükemmel ve el değmemiş bir zaman dilimi, sizin için artık mümkün değildir.
Penang’ta yine üç gün bir ‘otelin’ yatakhanesinde yalnızca aşağıdaki lokantaya inmelerinizle bölünen Dostoyevski okuduğunuz günleri hatırlarsınız. Nerdeyse bir sıla hasretiyle. Bir sürgün duygusuyla. Bir daha böyle günlerin, kapınıza umulmadık bir hediye gibi bırakılmayacağını eşekler gibi bilerek. Eşekler gibi mahzun ve derisi kalın. Gerçek ve derin, ipin ucu koyverilmiş, bedbahtlıklara bile artık zamanınız yoktur. Hiç yoktur.
Karı hissedemezsiniz. Yağmuru. Rüzgârı. Bir nevi izolasyon malzemesiyle tecrit edilmiştir ruhunuz ve bedeniniz. Doğayla ilişkiniz, hayatın doğallığıyla ilişkiniz kopmuş gitmiştir. Zavallı bir memursunuzdur. Artık herkes, bu hayatların her sabah kartını deldirmesi gereken, bitap memurlarıdır. Tüm arkadaşlarınız da sizin gibi enselenmişlerdir. Tesisat işleri, elektrik makbuzu, perdelerin yıkanması, yapılması gereken telefon konuşmaları, ödenmesi gereken borçlardan ibaretsinizdir.
Bazen arkadaşınızla karşılıklı şikâyet ve ağlaşmayla bir yarım saat geçirirsiniz. Yan yana oturup ‘Yüzbaşı Volkan’, ‘Dr. No’ okuduğunuz günlerin zavallı siluetleri olarak. Kavga bile edemezsiniz artık. Şiddetli kavgalar ve ağlamalar çoook gerilerdedir. Vızırdarsınız, cızırdarsınız, laf sokuşturursunuz. Siz artık siz değilsinizdir. Yeni bir insan da değilsinizdir. Zaruretleri yerine getirmekle mükellef bir kılıf. İçiniz boştur. Eskiden kalbin durduğu yerde kırık, imitasyon bir şeyler durur. ‘Şeyler’dir onlar. Gerçek hiçbir şey yoktur artık zira. Olamaz da.
Monday, July 14, 2008
I finally saw Sex and the City. It was fun, very shallow, with a few slightly "deeper" moments. At times I felt like I was watching a TV movie, a soap opera. Mr. Big's plastic face, his very childish freak-out when Miranda tells him he and Carrie are crazy to get married, Samantha's stalking of the man-next-door, prompting her to leave her first 'love,' Carrie deciding to make her wedding bigger when she decides to wear a bigger dress, the assistant girl going crazy when Carrie gives her a real Louis Vuitton... It's OK when it's on TV, it's not OK on the movie screen. All of it seemed like a lot of hot air, a colorful inflated balloon. The only character I could relate to was Charlotte, who was afraid of losing the blessings she had when her friends, who were all good people, were unhappy.
Then my friend pointed out something, which I think explained all this shallowness. None of these people in the movie had families. We saw no declining parents, no less glamourous siblings, cousins, aunts or uncles. Even in the TV series, the only parent we saw was Steve's mother. (Steve, by the way, is the only normal, real person in the whole show.) These people seem like they have nothing to worry about but their relationships! Nothing holds them back, makes them question their way of life, lose their balance. They have a light and two-dimensional existence. There is no past, only now, only future. Only going forward. Without thinking about, feeling for much else but themselves. This makes me a little motion-sick.
Saturday, February 23, 2008
I looked up the concept of "vefa" in the Turkish-English dictionary. Couldn't find an English equivalent that really describes it. Fidelity? Loyalty? Decency? Consistency? How boring, right?
Turkish writer Perihan Mağden wrote a wonderful column when our magnificent prime minister took her to court for "insulting him." She reminds the prime minister how she defended him, when he himself was convicted because of a poem he read. Then she says, she's not expecting "ahde vefa" from the prime minister. She says she only expects it from her equals, from the people she loves, from the ones who share similar opinions with her.
Maybe the solution is not to show "vefa", just so I won't expect it. I won't think about people, I won't care about them, I'll just spend time with them when I feel like it, as long as they keep me entertained. And I won't expect anything more from them, either - feel free to desert me as soon as I'm boring and heavy. Let's hang out as long as we drive sufficient utility from each other. Flexible markets, efficiency. As soon as you find a better option, disappear. It must be my fault to be who I am, falling short of your expectations.
I realize that there are quite a few people who think and act like that in my life, in my head. I'm not going to become one of them, not because I can't (because I am well capable of acting flaky, unfortunately I have before), but because I don't want to.
Somebody's loss, somebody's gain.
Wednesday, January 09, 2008
...
"The sister was trying to hear but Gyan had her by the braids and was pulling her home. Sai had betrayed him, led him to betray others, his own people, his family. She had enticed him, sneaked up on him, spied on him, ruined him, caused him to behave badly. He couldn't wait for the day his mother would show him the photograph of the girl he was to marry, a charming girl, he hoped, with cheeks like two Simla apples, who hadn't allowed her mind to traverse the gutters and gray areas, and he would adore her for the miracle she was.
"Sai was not miraculous; she was an uninspiring person, a reflection of all the contradictions around her, a mirror that showed him himself far too clearly for comfort."
page 259, 262, The Inheritance of Loss
(In)consistency
I was having tea with a friend of mine, and here's more or less how the conversation progressed:
"I still wonder why you called me intriguing," she said, referring to a birthday card I'd given her. "You don't say things for no reason, right?"
As I was about to reply, she went on: "Do you always think before you speak?"
"Not always, sometimes I realize what I say is not what I mean and it's disappointing," I thought and said. (I should have said, "no, I usually end up not speaking when I think.")
"Do you think people can always be rational?" she asked.
I went into a spiel about how we can never have enough information, we can never interpret it right - so no.
After a while I asked her:
"Do you think people who act emotional are stupid?"
Before all this we had talked about how a way of live becomes the norm in the society. How one's job becomes the most important thing in one's life, how everything else is supposed to be transient until we reach a certain age, how one has to be really ambitious if one wants to get somewhere. How we hang on to people only as long as they give us pleasure, and the moment they don't, we feel no obligation. I was referring to that.
"No," she said, getting me slightly wrong, going into the IQ vs. EQ debate, "those who are stupid are the ones who try to control everything, rationalize everything. You never know the reasons why someone acts a certain way - maybe they didn't get the toy they wanted when they were little...."
I didn't listen to the rest. She always accuses me of trying to rationalize everything. I was offended.
I do try to understand things, understand people, myself. I want clarity. Sometimes I eliminate my options just because I want some clarity. I decide I want a certain thing and block other possibilities. Maybe I want order, consistency, rules to live by. A definition of what is good and what is bad. What is right and what is wrong. What makes sense and what doesn't. What is meant to be and what isn't. What is conceivable and what is not.
People who want contradicting things all at once, people who believe in one thing now and another thing later puzzle me. You can't hold on to them. What is this then, a jungle? Don't we have any rules at all? Don't we learn anything from the past? Shouldn't we try to get out of this mess?
My friend has a point. Maybe I should lift the barriers in my mind, allow my mind to be free, allow myself to be inconsistent, disloyal to any one option. Jump into the mess rather than looking down at it from the sidelines, thinking it's beneath me. Alright.
***
"What kind of man are you?" she asked. "Is this any way to behave?"
"I'm confused," he said finally, reluctantly. "I'm only human and sometimes I'm weak. I'm sorry."
"At whose expense are you weak and human! You'll never get anywhere in life, my friend," shouted Sai, "if this is what you think makes an excuse...."
"I don't have to listen to this," he said jumping up and storming off abruptly just as she was in powerful flow.
And Sai had cried, for it was the unjust truth. page 249.
Thursday, November 22, 2007
"Be confident. People draw their strengths from your weaknesses," wrote my mom in an E-mail the last time I came back from Turkey. She also tells me to "keep the tail up" no matter what happens. I can't always follow her advice. I claim I don't want to pretend I'm better than I actually am. I claim it's dishonest. But the real reason is different, I think. First of all, I'm not smart enough. Secondly, I think sometimes being weak can be used as an excuse not to try harder. It's a comfortable place. I'm afraid I'll have to actually be better if I claim I'm better.
But I'm beginning to see my mom's point more and more. My year in London has been a crash course on real world: I've seen a lot that I hadn't before, but the more I see, the more doubtful and confused I get about myself, people, humanity. I discover and I forget - only to realize once again - we draw our strengths from others' weaknesses. Accepting this is maybe as genuine as we can get.
Everything is relative, after all. We need reference points. I'm intelligent if someone is less intelligent than me. I'm paid well if there are people around me who are paid less. If I take different reference points, I could well realize I'm actually not what I thought I was. I guess when you move up the ranks, you get more resistant to different contexts, you reach a more absolute, more robust feeling of success, value, confidence.
A couple of nights ago I went to have drinks with my new colleagues. Our big boss foot the bill (what's the past tense of "foot"?) so we shamelessly kept drinking. At first I really enjoyed the mood, much more relaxed, warmer, friendlier than in the office. But soon after I noticed that people were either gossipping about people not present (whom I didn't know) or talking about the competitors, the business. In the end, you couldn't really learn more about them than you could in the office.
So there's virtue in professionalism, putting on your poker face sometimes. But it's also important to let it down eventually, around some people. I guess it comes with time, trust.
Tuesday, November 13, 2007
for a long time I have been thinking about rules and books and strategies and human nature and being comfortable and pretending and standing behind yourself and insecurity and taking for granted and being taken for granted and being independent and posing a challenge and being challenged and I decided - no - no games. I want to be someone someone can count on - and I want to be able to count on someone. if that makes people predictable and boring, so be it.
(thanks to one of my friends who made me see this... she's a treasure! :)
...
after writing this, something made me doubt what I wrote. I believed in it when I wrote it, but then I realized sometimes people do not play games consciously, but they simply do not know what (or who) they want. they believe in one thing now - in another thing later. maybe it takes time. maybe they are trying to protect themselves by simply not wanting a specific thing, just so that they can pretend they didn't want it if they don't get it, and switch swiftly to wanting something else.
anyways - the consequences are the same either way, somebody gets hurt. and it is not fun not to want something wholeheartedly, because then you don't get happy when you actually get it, either. after going through all the arguments for and against - no games!
Saturday, October 20, 2007
During exams time, I wrote about Olson's observation of rational ignorance. In the same article, he wrote about the tendency of business practices, laws and regulations to become more sophisticated over time. Intelligent, sophisticated people come up with new, innovative ways to do business and make money all the time. Policy makers and legislators have to catch up with the suitable regulation and legislation. Then business people need lawyers, auditors, accountants and advisors to make sure they play by the rules (and find out if there were any gaps in the rules, any opportunities.) This all creates an exclusive, closed-circuit biosphere of intelligent, sophisticated people. You have to prove your intelligence, motivation and cunning to break into their circle and rise up to their level. You have to work very hard and build relationships. You have to pass the exams of their associations. All simply because they don't want the competition over-crowding brings.
And we are struggling to join the biosphere, not only because we need the money, but also because it's the only way we think we can prove our intelligence. Joining their circle seems like the best use of your time, something challenging enough. Something that can prove ourselves and the world that we are worthy. Look at the money we make. Look at the people we hang out with.
When I go to private equity conferences, I am envious. I feel like I'm looking at their circle from outside, because I'm not smart enough. I am dependent on the information they provide me within the few minutes of spare time they have, because they call the shots. Their time is important. This envy makes me want to join their circle. Become one of those smart girls who are always on their feet. It blurs my vision of what I really want to do and what is meaningful to me.
Thursday, October 11, 2007
I don't like shopping malls, supermarkets, where people try to push themselves (plus shopping carts and buggies) absent mindedly through corridors lit by white shining spots, and I found out I don't like IKEA, either. (I went to the one at home a few months ago, and I thought I liked it, and I imagined how I would shop there to decorate my place when I had a place - but no - I don't like it.)
I accept it, the idea is novel - you cut millions of pieces of wood and plastic and glass instead of hundreds - economies of scale. Then people make one trip for everything they need (and didn't know they need) instead of ten trips. You make order lists and stand in huge check out lines (a fight broke out in the adjacent line when I was there) and everything is oh-so-efficient and functional and clean-cut. So are our homes. But where is the individuality, where is the story of a coffee table you bought in Camden and carried all the way through Regent's Park? That would be special. But in IKEA, I don't see how anybody could feel special. I don't know if anyone cares.
Still, it was nice to have good friends along to stand on the check out line with and endure the sickening bus ride to and from Wembley. Maybe that's the key to feeling special. Being with special people who think you're special. Then you don't even wonder whether you're special, because you know you are. Something like that.
Sunday, September 02, 2007
...is so easy.
Wednesday, August 01, 2007
Why are we meanest to the people who clearly love us, who are the most vulnerable in front of us? Why are we impatient, tactless, thoughtless with the ones that care the most for us, do the most for us? I frown at my family like I can to no other. I say whatever to my closest friends. Because I know they will stay. I'm horrible to guys who make the mistake of liking me. Because I know I've already won them. There is nothing to be won anymore. They are not interesting anymore. There is no challenge.
I'm strong against someone because I don't care. Somebody else is strong against me because they don't care. They will just read what I write for them and they will find it cheesy, pathetic. I will read what the others write for me and I will find it cheesy, pathetic.
Even now, writing this, I know I'm being weak and uninteresting and unmysterious. But the unfairness in this actually breaks my heart, that's why I'm writing it. The only way to win the admiration of people is to stay independent of their influence, out of their reach. Loving someone is not enough reason to be loved back. Being strong and independent is what makes people admirable.
Friday, July 27, 2007
you see a lot of people walking fast. fat people. good-looking people. well-dressed bankers. lawyers. people with thinning hair and receding hairlines. blonde frizzy hair, burnt from too much intervention. huge afros. red beautiful hair that moves as one mass. tired people. people walking fast, ignited with an unexplainable source of motivation. people waiting for the bus. crazy guy with horribly long rasta hair. two japanese men passed out from the gentle massage at the hair dresser. people talking on the phone with a smile on their faces. couples kissing. really handsome guys with perfect hair. middle aged fit women with a really rough mask on their faces, like they've been out in the cold for too long. old, tired men in trenchcoats with sleepy eyes. women in suits, tights and sneakers. small fat women. women checking themselves out on shop windows. sometimes I just pick one person and look at them hard. sometimes they have a smile for no apparent reason. interesting thing watching people when they are not interacting with anyone, when they are walking alone, submerged in their own thoughts and worries. some of them self-conscious with muscles on their faces twitching, some of them truly lost in thought. all these cells in the blood that circulates in the london streets. addicted to running. then, each of these cells has a life. each of them is in a bloated, all-so-important bubble of their own. imagine everyone having a life just like your own! so much information, so much memory and emotion, yet each of them a huge isolated bubble. they have hopes, disappointments, connections, people who care for them. and then they are just a cell in blood, so ordinary. no apparent reason to pay attention to them separately, because they are all like one another. london will spit them out soon.
how many people really pay attention to me? I think I'm so special, but noone seems to care. where do I stand on that big, invisible ladder that ranks people? we are immune to even the best now, because there are too many of them, so who should care about me when I'm clearly not the best? I hate it when people on the street look through me, turning their eyes quickly, not finding me interesting enough to really look at. I would always imagine passerby's admired me, but now I know they don't. but how many of them catch my attention anyway? we just pass by. nowadays I feel very ordinary, very unimportant. I hate that.
Thursday, May 10, 2007
Girls' Code
I have a few regular readers and they make me so happy by coming back often. I only know some of them, and finding out the identity of the others might creep me out, so I want to thank you without asking any questions :) I don't want to disappoint you now, I want to write good stuff.
Today's topic is girl friendships. I'm sure there are books about this, but if they want a new one, they should commission me, for I am the expert. I grew up in a family with many women and relatively few men, and I've always been in large circles of girl-friends. In elementary school we used to have a talent show every year, where we danced to pop songs with my six or seven girlfriends. I was in another group in middle school, and our pastime was to call our crushes out of the blue and break into their lockers, but the group broke in half when we started high school and some of us proved to be more alternative-minded. I got into trouble for my girlfriends, too, I once got a disciplinary warning for having helped a friend write a hate-letter to a boy. Of course there was nothing in that for me, but I guess I was proud that my literary skills were being appreciated. She annoyed me much by crying the whole time we were getting scolded.
Since elementary school, the rituals of girl groups didn't change much. Pyjama parties where everyone tell their little secrets, little comments, little questions that aim to put the respondent on the spot, competition. And all those silly things I told you about. We are all way over 20 now, and still every conversation culminates in one topic. Those girls magazines and soap operas really shouldn't worry about coming up with anything new - we will read the same stories and relationship advice over and over as if we never heard them before.
Looking back on it, I realize how funny it all was. I was reading and writing and attending philosophy olympics and science fairs - and my friends did, too, but we also did those silly, childish, shallow things. It's no different from a gang of boys, who would do anything to belong to a group. We didn't have a mind of our own.
Why did we do that? The girls group provides a comfortable caccoon of social interaction and information. You stand in a hall of mirrors, all those girls in the mirrors understand you, reassure you, encourage you, tell you their weaknesses and desires, you tell them your weaknesses and desires, you find out everybody has the same weaknesses and desires. Everybody is loving and sharing and understanding.
Not always. Sometimes they do or say something that makes you realize that your friend isn't so benevolent, after all. They bring up something you shared with them long ago. They ask you a question and you know they know the answer, but they take the pleasure of hearing it from you. What's the point, I used to ask myself. I always wondered, what's the point in all this meanness? Aren't they scared of losing their friend? How will I trust this girl again?
There's always that underlying competition, there's always schadenfreude, but shouldn't we try to go over and beyond that and genuinely wish each other well? Maybe I'm kidding myself. Too many times I took pride in being better than a girl in something or another. Too many times I was bitter that I did worse than my friend. I tried to hide it as well as I could. When inequalities grew larger, we could no longer sustain the friendship. It was no longer reassuring and comfortable, one of us had grown out of the caccoon.
Maybe this is how it should be. Being good for the sake of being good is out of fashion. People see relationships as sources of personal fulfillment, and they don't feel much responsibility towards a relationship that isn't fun and light. Maybe I shouldn't expect anyone to go out of their way not to hurt my feelings. I shouldn't expect anyone to constrain themselves for me.
Monday, March 12, 2007
Yesterday I went to Gilbert & George exhibition at Tate Modern. The artists lived and created art in London's East End (on Fournier Street close to Spitalfields, my neighborhood!) since early 70's. Trained as sculptors, they started out as "living sculptures," and soon after they started making photomontages, usually taking themselves as subjects, alongside views of dirty London streets, water poddles, flashlights, cherry blossoms, their bare wooden apartment, young boys, crosses, graffitti, sex ads, tabloid headlines, Gincko leaves, people who look like they belong to the fringes: Muslims, black people, "white trash." (Not to mention penises, spunk, shit and their own arses.) They force you to look at your own dark side in the eye. (And this exhibition forces London to look at her dark side in the eye.)
As it happens when I see modern art most of the time, I was quick to conclude that these artists could not do anything else with their lives, so they decided to do this (continuing in the Hincal Uluç vein, who rightly wrote once that he couldn't be convinced that a black square is art, and even Ertuğrul Özkök vein, "let's all admit our unliberal, intolerant side and relax now!") This alludes to a lack of talent, motivation, structure and patience in everything else that would earn them their living and respect, rather than a specific talent, motivation, structure and patience in art. When I look at an art piece, I'd like to see traces of talent, genius (something new, creative, something that would uncover an idea or emotion in me I didn't realize was there), beauty and discipline. I'd like to see advancement, something greater than myself, something I wouldn't have been able to do. To me, an artist, and any other discipline, should try to rise above and beyond himself, his daily life, his human instincts in his work, rather than making money and a reputation of them. (Advancement, not democracy!!)
So here I am, sounding like your mother or teacher. Being the reflective person I am, of course, this is not the end of the story. Firstly, looking at it from an economic point of view, these artists seem to have made a living with their work. (Watch the videos on the Tate web-site, they look like they made quite a lot since they were able to invest in that technology!) So there are people who like their art, who find something in it. What they are doing clearly has value. (At the same time, sometimes I wonder whether critiques are afraid of criticizing art just because they don't want to sound unliberal.)
They also seem to be working very hard while they are creating their art, albeit its ugliness much of the time. But then, we want creativity, we want new things that would speak to the society we live in now. So we can no longer expect the beauty and technique of Renaissance painting or impressionists or surrealists. That's all been done before. So we have to keep an open mind.
Furthermore, who am I to judge, right? Of course it doesn't speak to much in me because I've mostly been one of the privileged as a Caucasian woman from a middle class background. I don't understand those in the minority, gays, poor, excluded. But I know that most of the time, it takes patience, hard work and structure to improve your life. So while it is interesting and important to recognize, I don't see much to be proud of in clinging on to that alternative culture. The message about racism and religious fundamentalism, while original and interesting at the time, although still relevant, is not that original anymore.
But even to me, there were a few highlights. The sex ads, tabloid headlines and images of my neighborhood - contrasted against cherry blossoms. And the red.
Definitely worth seeing since it sparked so much to talk about!