The struggle of man against power is the struggle of memory against forgetting. Milan Kundera.
Sunday, October 25, 2009
Saturday, October 10, 2009
The questions that need to be asked to bring about the transition from a "global market" to a "global society" can be very exciting and inspiring. They give people’s lives a meaning beyond day-to-day survival characterised by tedious office jobs, family lives and consumerism. They give each person a stake in improving the humanity’s well-being, bringing about change. This is what today’s left-wing politics should embrace. People would be far more receptive to this than we (and politicians) think. Only one leader fully grasps this: Obama.
Tuesday, October 06, 2009
Saturday, October 03, 2009
-And-
I certainly haven't been spreading myself around
I still only travel by foot and by foot, it's a slow climb,
But I'm good at being uncomfortable, so
I can't stop changing all the time
I notice that my opponent is always on the go
-And-
Won't go slow, so's not to focus, and I notice
He'll hitch a ride with any guide, as long as
They go fast from whence he came
- But he's no good at being uncomfortable, so
He can't stop staying exactly the same
If there was a better way to go then it would find me
I can't help it, the road just rolls out behind me
Be kind to me, or treat me mean
I'll make the most of it, I'm an extraordinary machine
I seem to you to seek a new disaster every day
You deem me due to clean my view and be at peace and lay
I mean to prove I mean to move in my own way, and say,
I've been getting along for long before you came into the play
I am the baby of the family, it happens, so
- Everybody cares and wears the sheeps' clothes
While they chaperone
Curious, you looking down your nose at me, while you appease
- Courteous, to try and help - but let me set your
Mind at ease
(Chorus)
-Do I so worry you, you need to hurry to my side?
-It's very kind
But it's to no avail; I don't want the bail
I promise you, everything will be just fine
If there was a better way to go then it would find me
I can't help it, the road just rolls out behind me
Be kind to me, or treat me mean
I'll make the most of it, I'm an extraordinary machine
Thursday, October 01, 2009
Wednesday, September 23, 2009
Saturday, September 19, 2009
"It became apparent that the "modern" worldview, which explained the world in terms of 'states and failed states' and which was shared by both the US and the Soviet Union during the Cold War, no longer sufficed to explain what is truly going on in the world today and why. However, the objective truth of the modern world was not replaced by a new objective truth.
Now we are left with post-modernist "accounts," subjective opinions of self-appointed experts, because we often lack hard data about the nature or severity the problems we face. Policy makers and states now use the "precautionary principle," (thanks to the Bush administration) which presupposes that you don't have to wait for conclusive hard evidence to act against a perceived threat. The way "experts" frame the problems, or "questions" at hand, determines our response to these problems. The academic gave the example of HIV/AIDS. Is it a developmental problem or a security problem? The answer we give to this question will determine which actors will tackle it, what they will do to solve it, and what resources will be spent on it. We can think of many other examples. Take terrorism or climate change.
Although we often don't have hard evidence and easy answers, it is still important to try to understand the actors we are dealing with. For example, the West perceives China as a rising power, a competitive force so competitive precisely because it does not respect the rules. But it is difficult for Westerners to convince China that complying with international labor and environmental standards, reining in on corruption and crime, and refusing to deal with the likes of Hassan al-Bashir will be good for the Chinese in the long-term. China needs high economic growth in the short-term to maintain social peace." From my article, Leading Uneasy Lives, 17 January 2009."Also in 2001, Bent Flyvbjerg in his book Making Social Science Matter identified a way out of the Science Wars by arguing that (1) social science is phronesis, whereas natural science is episteme, in the classical Greek meaning of the terms; (2) phronesis is well suited for the reflexive analysis and discussion of values and interests, which any society needs to thrive, whereas episteme is good for the development of predictive theory, and; (3) a well-functioning society needs both phronesis and episteme in balance, and one cannot substitute for the other." From the Wikipedia entry, Science Wars.
"[Sociology is ] ... the science whose object is to interpret the meaning of social action and thereby give a causal explanation of the way in which the action proceeds and theeffects which it produces. By 'action' in this definition is meant the human behaviour when and to the extent that the agent or agents see it assubjectively meaningful ... the meaning to which we refer may be either (a) the meaning actually intended either by an individual agent on a particular historical occasion or by a number of agents on an approximate average in a given set of cases, or (b) the meaning attributed to the agent or agents, as types, in a pure type constructed in the abstract. In neither case is the 'meaning' to be thought of as somehow objectively 'correct' or 'true' by some metaphysical criterion. This is the difference between the empirical sciences of action, such as sociology and history, and any kind of prioridiscipline, such as jurisprudence, logic, ethics, or aesthetics whose aim is to extract from their subject-matter 'correct' or 'valid' meaning." – Max Weber The Nature of Social Action 1922, from the Wikipedia entryAntipositivism.
A few thoughts on social sciences
When I studied economics in university I considered subjects like sociology, anthropology, cultural studies, psychology and even politics "soft." They didn't give definite answers, there was little way of "falsifying" them. Because they couldn't be tested, it was hard to tell their value. But then I realized, as with many things, social reality isn't something that could be understood easily.
Once a senior colleague explained me the three ways of approaching social reality (please correct me if I'm missing something). Durkheim believed that the society was like an organism; interdependent actors and institutions performed different, but complementary functions in it. The characteristics and health of a society could be studied objectively. Marx argued that the power struggle between distinct groups gave rise to social action and conflict. Weber thought that there was no objective social reality, neither the meaning an outsider gives to an action nor the insider's intention in performing that action could be taken as its objective meaning.
We unconsciously draw from all three approaches while trying to make sense of social reality. However, I find Weber's insights particularly useful. The outsider should shed her preconceived opinions and try to understand the context, imagine. The insider should shed her interests in that particular context and try to judge her actions against more objective benchmarks.
Tuesday, September 08, 2009
Monday, August 24, 2009
Wednesday, August 19, 2009
Apparently, once Mevlana Celaleddin Rumi described his life story with the simple line, “I was raw, I cooked, I burned.” I’ve been thinking about that a lot lately. I don’t have any claim on the spiritual connotations, obviously. I simply feel like some truth is escaping me, but I have no idea what it is. Sometimes writing really is like walking in the dark.
A good friend of mine got quite disappointed in me for not speaking openly about my disappointment in her. I gave her these long-winded explanations, bitter that she got the upper hand in our little philosophical debate: She was accusing me of being insincere, me, “the defender of sincerity and truth”! She was confident that my action was flawed at a much deeper, more fundamental level than hers, everything I was saying was obvious and beside the point, and I lacked the appreciation of a fundamental, common value... but what?
Then this morning I remembered something I wrote to another friend a few months ago. I wrote, “if I’m telling the feelings and thoughts you spark in me not to you, but to others – then no, we are not close.” And I remembered that I felt really strongly about it. So I did have this notion buried somewhere, I just forgot… I guess this is not a good enough answer.
The question then is; why am I not telling what I should to these people? People have their reasons for keeping quiet. There are different levels of relationships. Sometimes we foresake a higher, closer, more fulfilling relationship for security, peace and quiet, and just stay at that lower, “civil” level. We don’t rock the boat. The same can be said for foresaking dreams, principles, the truth. And when we don’t face and speak the truth, we are insincere. Sincerity is not just about sharing the most mundane details of your life and feelings. Ayca Sen wrote a beautiful piece about this yesterday.
And the reason I do this is simply my insecurity. If I don’t try for something better, I will never have to face my true worth.
Last night I also remembered something I wrote when I was sixteen. The girl I was then doesn’t like the person I turned out to be. Perhaps I am living a Benjamin Button lifestyle, turning raw as years go by.
Thursday, August 13, 2009
Sunday, August 09, 2009
Monday, August 03, 2009
Sunday, August 02, 2009
"In each of us there are different talents, different propensities, many of them capable of good or evil use. We must endeavour to know our possibilities and use what energy we really possess in the doing of God's will. As spiritual beings, in our imperfections and also in the possibility of our perfection, we differ profoundly one from another. How different we are from each other is something which it may take a long time to find out; and certain differences may never appear at all. Each one of us has his own way of apprehending God. I am sure you will know what I mean when I say that one finds God, as it were, in certain places; one has, where God is concerned, a sense of direction, a sense that here is what is most real, most good, most true. This sense of reality and weight attaches itself to certain experiences in our lives - and for different people these experiences may be different. God speaks to us in various tongues. To this, we must be attentive." pg. 209-210.
Thursday, July 30, 2009
Saturday, July 25, 2009
Geçen hafta Yükseköğretim Kurulu (YÖK), meslek lisesi öğrencilerinin kendi alanlarından başka bir alanda üniversite öğrenimi yapmak istemeleri halinde orta öğretim başarı puanlarının daha düşük bir katsayıyla çarpılması uygulamasına son verdi. Bu uygulama 1999'daki bir YÖK kararına dayanıyordu, AKP 2004'te katsayıları kaldıran bir yasayı meclisten geçirmiş, ancak dönemin cumhurbaşkanı Sezer yasayı veto etmişti. AKP o zaman konunun üstüne daha fazla gitmedi. Bu sırada YÖK'te AKP'yle aynı görüşteki üyeler çoğunluğu kazandı, bu karar da en sonunda "normal yollardan" alınabildi. Yargıtay onursal başsavcısı Sabih Kanadoğlu kararı kimin iptal edebileceğini söylemiş bile: Danıştay.
Thursday, July 23, 2009
Monday, July 13, 2009
I.
Tuesday, July 07, 2009
Bugun Hrant Dink davasindaki tanigin ifadesini okurken, kaderin ne demek olabilecegini dusundum. O tanik hanim, isminin gazetelerde belirecegini, saniklarla benzer kafa yapisina ve goruslere sahip kimselerin, hatta saniklarin azmettiricilerinin hedefi olabilecegini bile bile, korkusuzca taniklik yapmis. Sonra soyle dedim: Bu tanigin kisiligine sahip birisi, karsisina boyle bir olay ciktiginda, boyle davraniyor. Bir denklem gibi bir sey bu. Birini iyi tanidiginizda da degisik durumlar karsisinda ne tavir alabilecegini kestirebilirsiniz ya. Bu tanigin Hrant Dink’in ofisine yakin calismasi, Dink’in vurulmasina sahit olmasi tamamen tesaduf. Sahit oldugu olaya tepkisi ise tesaduf degil, aslinda ozgur irade de degil, kendi kontrol edemedigi, karar vermedigi bir seye, oldugu insana boyun egis. Cunku baska turlu davransa ici rahat etmeyecek, kendine ihanet etmis olacak. Hayatin karsimiza cikardigi olaylara ve insanlara tepkimiz, bizi iyi taniyanlarin malumudur aslinda. Kendimizi biliyorsak, bizim de.
Thursday, July 02, 2009
Today Ali Sirmen from the Cumhuriyet newspaper appeared on Ruşen Çakır's and Mirgün Cabas' Yazı İşleri on NTV. I don't like repeating myself or other people, but sometimes you have to keep making the same point. Here's a little backgrounder:
Last week, our parliament passed a law that transfers the authority to try military personnel from military courts to civil courts for crimes against state security, the government, judiciary and the constitutional order, as well as forming an armed organization. This applies to the soldiers, who are accused of being involved with the Ergenekon plot to overthrow the AKP government. In fact, the government appears to have deliberately targeted them with this new law. The most prominent one is colonel Dursun Çiçek, the alleged author of the strategy to "finish" reactionary Islam and the Fethullah Gülen brotherhood. He was arrested for his alleged involvement with Ergenekon a couple of days ago, only to be released by the same civil court yesterday.
The new law is an EU accession requirement, and an outsider would view it as a step towards a sounder democracy, making soldiers more accountable to civilians. This would be the case if our judiciary was truly independent. However, some of the prosecutors and judges (as well as the police) are ideologically motivated. One of the judges has withdrawn from the case due to what he called "institutional pressures." The suspects of the Ergenekon investigation have been under arrest for a long time without a trial. The indictments are so complex that even well meaning judges would take a very long time to untangle them. We may never find out the truth.
In this environment, it is not possible to be happy about a reform, knowing that the roots of the problem lay much deeper. The judiciary and security forces are used as weapons in this power struggle, leaving Turkish citizens with a deep suspicion about these institutions' willingness and ability to protect their rights and freedoms.
Monday, June 22, 2009
Last week I attended a lecture by Professor Dani Rodrik from Harvard University at the LSE. Rodrik is a political economist, who is deeply interested in the institutions that regulate and govern markets. His presentation (slides can be downloaded here) was a genuine attempt to come up with a way to build a more sustainable system of markets and institutions.
Why did we find ourselves in this crisis? Because of the absence of financial regulation and "global macro imbalances," which led to large current account surpluses in emerging markets like China and large deficits in the US and some other emerging markets, Rodrik said. Deep economic integration (in finance and trade) was not accompanied by the necessary rules, regulations and institutions on a global level. Admittedly a constructivist, Rodrik said brand new ideas could fill the vacuum created by the failure of conventional thinking. And he did his share of brainstorming - an effort which confronted challenges from a suspecting audience, but still managed to show some important inconsistencies in our thinking and conduct.
For example, labor, environmental, health and safety standards differ from one country to the other, but countries still import products from trading partners with a completely different set of rules and values. One might complain about the labor practices in factories supplying Primark stores, but imposing western standards on developing countries would deprive third-world workers of their comparative advantage. In fact, prevalent economic norms advocating free trade and denouncing currency manipulation and industrial policies already limit the policies available to developing countries.
Even the European Union, which hopes to narrow the differences between its member states by a strenuous and costly accession process, suffers from great resistance to attempts at deeper integration. Although member states adopted a common currency, they are wary of any kind of fiscal integration/redistribution between member states. Their slow and limited response to the crisis (and the most recent reluctance regarding supra-national financial supervision) are the latest examples.
Rodrik recognizes that wide differences between countries render global regulations, standards and fiscal safety nets unrealistic - and undesirable, too. He argues for a system which will allow countries to integrate as much as they want, and govern the relationship between those that are different. Countries opt-out when necessary, but they do so within a framework. A greater policy space (subsidies, industrial policy) is provided to developing nations. There's no single, universal truth, but a variety of norms that are most suitable for a variety of circumstances. Expectations and conduct are aligned by not only changing the conduct, but also adjusting expectations.
Rodrik gives the example of the safeguard clause in the WTO, which defines a set of rules under which it is possible to deviate from free trade. If there is a surge in imports, countries can impose restrictions on a non-discriminatory basis and provide compensation to their trade partners. Refreshingly, he says that segmentation in global financial markets may be a welcome price to pay for the preservation of national policies and regulations reflecting country differences.
The greatest challenge to Rodrik's framework is the question of legitimacy - do countries' policies really reflect their citizens' preferences? The professor himself admitted that his argument did not hold for undemocratic societies. But then there was the question, who is fully democratic? Members of the audience rightfully pointed out that even the American democracy is flawed in important ways, and large groups of Americans lose out.
Even then, I liked Rodrik's presentation, because it was realistic and idealistic at the same time. Even if the policies pursued by developing states do not reflect their citizens' preferences, who can say that the policies devised in the developed world will fit the developing world any better? In the former, country elites rule, in the latter, world elites.
However, it is important to avoid the legitimisation of undemocratic regimes in the meantime. Different policies may be acceptable for different levels of economic development, but I don't believe in different shades of democracy. When it comes to democracy and human rights, there should be absolute, universal norms. Country circumstances should not be an excuse to submit to oppression - they should only be the guide as how to best help bring about democracy.
A friend of mine says, power creates its truth. This is true on different levels, international, national, regional. That's why the dissemination of political power is so important. Maybe Americans got it right: Democracy and prosperity are ends in themselves. They just get the means wrong, because there is more than one way.
Sunday, June 14, 2009
Imagine you're walking in the woods. In the shadows of pine trees, surrounded by a soft breeze, rays of sunlight filter through the branches and the needles. Sometimes you look up and see a blue sky with healthy, chubby clouds. You walk and walk, and then quite unexpectedly reach a clearing.
Goethe once said, "one hears only what one understands." There's so much information out there, cries of discovery, love, joy, pain - everybody is telling a story. In this clearing, you start listening to more voices, hearing them, and you understand them. Even the ones you've heard before, they sound fuller now, they mean more. There are levels of understanding, and you think you understand them a notch better. Maybe not completely, but better.
There are still so many voices that escape you, and then there are those you think you understand but haven't yet. One only finds out one hasn't understood something the moment one understands it better. You keep walking and you'll find out.
Friday, June 12, 2009
ah how I hate the Londoners on the underground. how savage they look sometimes. they take space, and their bags take space, and their glances take space. with their every breath, the air becomes more stale. they push and stand in my way.
sometimes I wonder, what magnificent and rebellious thoughts are passing through their minds, when they look so ordinary and pale. I know because I look so ordinary and pale.
but during these two days, I loved the Londoners. because of their energy and drive and color and joy in so much misery, because of their style and attitude. ordinary yet special. strangely equal, more or less. I realized why we live here despite everything. the buzz of countless possibilities presented by freedom and anonymity and links and crossing ways.
it was a bonding experience, the shared reality of being a Londoner. like the snow day. and the sunny day.
Saturday, June 06, 2009
Orhan Pamuk Kara Kitap’ın 158. sayfasında şöyle der: “Hep birlikte inanacakları bir hikaye kalmayınca, hepsi tek tek kendi hikayesine inanmaya başlayacak, herkesin kendi hikayesi olacak, herkes kendi hikayesini anlatmak isteyecek. Kalabalık şehirlerin kirli sokaklarında, bir türlü çekidüzen verilemeyen çamurlu meydanlarında, milyonlarca sefil, başlarının çevresinde bir mutsuzluk halesi taşır gibi taşıdıkları kendi hikayeleriyle uykuda gezerler gibi gezinecekler.”
Üniversitede toplu eylem problemini öğrenmiştik – toplu eylemsizlik problemini yani. Küçük çıkar grupları ortak bir amaç uğruna çalışabiliyorlardı, ortak bir hikayeye inanabiliyorlardı. Ama on binleri, yüz binleri bir amaç uğruna birleştirebilmek, bir hikayeye inandırabilmek mümkün olmuyordu. Ya her şeyin olduğu gibi kalmasının kendi hayatlarını zorlaştırdığını, daha iyisinin mümkün olabileceğini görmüyorlardı, ya da harcayacakları çabanın boşa gideceğini düşünüyorlardı. Kimse birbirine güvenmiyordu, herkes kendi hikayesinin içine hapsolmuş, başını bir an o mutsuzluk halesinden çıkarmıyordu. Hiç bir şey değişmeyecekti, önemli olan mevcut düzenin önümüze çıkardığı bin bir engeli aşabilmek, fırtınalı denizlerde kendi canımızı kurtarmaktı.
Boğaziçi Üniversitesi’nden Hakan Yılmaz, 2 Haziran’da Londra’da, LSE’de Türkiye’de kamuoyunun Avrupa Birliği’ne ve “batılı değerlere” bakışı ile ilgili bir sunum yaptı. Konuşmasının bir yerinde Türkiye’de gençlerin Avrupa Birliği’ni hiç takmadıklarını söyledi. Tabii bunda Avrupalıların sonunda üye olabileceğimize inanmayalım diye gösterdikleri çabanın rolü yadsınamaz. Ama burda sorun Avrupa Birliği’ne üyelik değil aslında. Avrupa Birliği, bir şeyleri değiştirmek için bir bahaneden başka bir şey değil.
Asıl önemli olan değişimi istemek. Türkiye’de polislerin, askerlerin, hakimlerin, savcıların, bürokratların, politikacıların ve aslında herkesin işini biraz daha düzgün yapması önemli olan. İnsanların emeklerinin ve yeteneklerinin karşılığını alabilmesi, kendilerini dürüstçe, korkusuzca ifade edebilmesi. Adil düzen böyle bir şey olmalı. Şu anda farkında değiliz belki, belki güvendeyiz, işimiz tıkırında, kimseyle bir problemimiz yok. Hatta belki sistem lehimize işliyor. Ama bunlar gerçekleşse şu anda farkında olmadığımız o kadar çok fırsat çıkacak ki önümüze. Enerjimizi öyle farklı alanlarda kullanabileceğiz ki. O yaşadığım da hayat mıymış diyeceğiz.
Bütün bunları kabul etsek bile korkmakta haksız değiliz aslında. Bir şeyleri değiştirmeye, iyileştirmeye çalışanların başına gelenler çok taze anılarımızda. İnsanlar nasıl ağızları yandığında yoğurdu üfleyerek yiyorlarsa, toplumlar da öyle. “Hata”larımızdan ders almışız, akıllanmışız, kendi hikayemizden başka hiç bir hikayeye inanmamayı öğrenmişiz. Göze çarpmamalı, bunun için de görmezden gelmeliyiz.
Ama birileri var. Hadi itiraf edelim, korkuyoruz onlardan. Bizi oyuna getirecekler sanıyoruz. Türlü türlü cemaatler, dernekler, tarikatlar, Fethullahçılar, Masonlar, Ergenekoncular, sivil toplum örgütleri, sendikalar ve hatta siyasi partiler – kendi çıkarları için olsun olmasın, ortak bir hikayeye inananlardan korkuyoruz. Çünkü içten içe farkındayız, ortak bir hikayeye inananların, ortak bir amaç için çalışanların ne kadar güçlü olabileceğinin, ne kadar çok şey yapabileceğinin. Belki onlar bizim hayatımızı etkiliyorlar, değiştiriyorlar. Belki hangi yönde olduğunu bilsek, hoşumuza gitmezdi.
Ama biz zaten hangi yöne gitmek istiyoruz ki?
This week I went to a dance performance at Sadler's Wells - Wayne McGregor's Random Dance - Entity. Earlier I had seen a flamenco show by Spanish National Ballet in the same venue, and had gotten exactly the same impression:
One is not supposed to see some hidden comprehensible meaning looking at these performances. There is not an idea or meaning they are pointing at - other than themselves. They just are. More importantly, they do. One gets a feeling of attitude and decisiveness looking at the dancers. They don't have a moment to think, to hesitate. Looking at the beauty of the performance, they seem like for months and for years, they never hesitated. They just believed in the beauty of what they were doing.
I love that idea. Believing in something so much that never hesitating.
Friday, June 05, 2009
bir varmış bir yokmuş
yeryüzündeki metaforlar gökyüzündeki meteorlar kadar çokmuş.
gökyüzünde yalnız gezen yıldızlar varmış.
bir gün yolları kesişmiş,
biraz da beraber gezelim demişler.
ama yollarını değiştirmemişler,
korkmuşlar birbirlerinin yörüngesine girip sürüklenmekten.
ama kendi yolundan gitmek de zormuş
yorucu işler(miş) bunlar.
Tuesday, June 02, 2009
birbirini takip eden anlar olsun
ve birinin ardından diğerinin gelmesinin bir nedeni olsun
kimse açıklayamasa da neden
oldukları gibi olmamaları düşünülemez olsun
günah olsun bir tanesini değiştirmek
bir sonrakinin tohumu bir önceki
en sonuncusunun içinde birincisi